Re: Yet Another Opinion That Skins Need A GM
 

[quote=FRPLG;408068]I am so tired of this argument. I dont necessarily disagree but it has been made so many times and it is obviuos that they are not going to do it. I wish the media would just move on. There is no one alive who cares about football who does not know that EVERYONE thinks they need a GM and that Snyder doesn't. It simply isn't going to happen. Maybe some day but I seriously doubt what the media thinks or what we as fasn think has any bearing on it.[/quote]

THANK YOU!!

Re: Yet Another Opinion That Skins Need A GM
 

[quote=skinsnut;408091]Isn't DePaul with the BEARS?
You want a GM from THERE?

Didn't they pay Archuleta's Redskin bonus to get him after he flopped?
What about their QB disaster situation.
I'm not a fan of the Bears moves...
I'm sick of Casserly too...that dude didn't do so well....westbrook?....shuler?

I like the Reese, GWilliams combo idea best[/quote]

The Bears have a solid young team, they've just missed on their qb selections, which is hardly uncommon. They went to the super bowl w/a pretty low payroll as I recall.

btw, I think Orton can be a decent starter if they give him time.

Re: Yet Another Opinion That Skins Need A GM
 

[QUOTE=Bill B;408049]I am hoping that is Greg Williams gets the job he is allowed to bring in Floyd Reese as the GM - that would be a perfect scenario for the Skins and would solidfy our FO.[/QUOTE]


I think it's highly unlikely that Gregg Williams, even if he is named head coach will have any impact on whether Dan Snyder does,
or does not hire a GM. In most cases it's the other way around.

However, I would like to see Snyder pressed on the issue as to why he's so adamant in his belief, borrowing his phrase "If it ain't broke, don't fix it" It is broken, and needs to be fixed. I have my own opinion as to why he won't hire a GM, but I'll leave that for another discussion.

Re: Yet Another Opinion That Skins Need A GM
 

Washington does not need a GM.

Williams has been heavily involved with player aquisitions via draft and free agency for the past 4 years. (snyder and vinny)

When we drafted Sean Taylor a TE was also a need. Winslow was up and alot of us thought Gibbs would take a TE. Shows GW's influence.

He is an amazing talent evaluator on the defensive side and I'm sure that will translate well to the offensive side, as long as Al Saunders stays in the mix as well.

Re: Yet Another Opinion That Skins Need A GM
 

[QUOTE=skinsnut;408091]Isn't DePaul with the BEARS?
You want a GM from THERE?

Didn't they pay Archuleta's Redskin bonus to get him after he flopped?
What about their QB disaster situation.
I'm not a fan of the Bears moves...
I'm sick of Casserly too...that dude didn't do so well....westbrook?....shuler?

I like the Reese, GWilliams combo idea best[/QUOTE]

Here's his bio, he worked for us before and has local roots having played at Maryland and so forth.


[B]
Bobby DePaul, in his sixth year as the Bears director of pro personnel, has played an instrumental role to Chicago’s two division championships achieved during his tenure with the team. Hired on June 19, 2001, the 17-year NFL veteran came to Chicago after serving as a member of the Philadelphia Eagles player personnel department for four years following an eight-year career as an NFL assistant coach.

DePaul evaluates players in the professional ranks, prepares the club for its acquisitions through free agency or the waiver wire and manages the advance scouting for Bears opponents. In addition to supervising the pro personnel department, DePaul has a hand in day-to-day football operations, assisting with salary cap maintenance, contract negotiations and overseeing the development of scouting football systems technology.

DePaul entered the NFL in 1989, hired by former Bears defensive back Richie Petitbon as a member of Joe Gibbs’ coaching staff at Washington where he stayed until 1993 after winning an NFL championship with the Redskins’ Super Bowl XXVI victory over Buffalo. The Bowie, Md., native then served on the Bengals coaching staff for three seasons before joining the Eagles as a scout.

Born in 1963, DePaul attended Archbishop John Carroll High School in Washington, D.C., where he played fullback and linebacker on a team that lost only once during his three-year varsity career. DePaul attended the University of Maryland and played linebacker on three Atlantic Coast Conference champion Terrapin squads and made four bowl appearances under former Detroit Lions and San Diego Chargers head coach Bobby Ross. DePaul and his wife, Lisa, have two daughters, Ariel and Ashley.[/B]

Re: Yet Another Opinion That Skins Need A GM
 

[quote=freddyg12;408093]If the current structure is successful in the draft & builds a young solid team, does the team still need a proper GM? Who knows what the role of the next head coach will be in personel, but it looks like it will be the same 3 headed monster. I have no problems w/how the front office is structured so long as they make sound decisions & field a consistent winner.

Give Danny, Vinny & GW a chance at building through the draft & minimizing free agent signings, then we can see if the team really needs a structural change in the front office.[/quote]

That's just it, they haven't built a consistent winner. DS/Vinny have been here for how long 8 years? Our record is mediocre at best. Our talent vs other teams is mediocre.

We have made some decent draft choices recently. We've also made some BAD FA signings too (some good too). I just don't trust DS/Vinny to build a team thru the draft. It's not gonna change so i hope they prove me wrong.

Re: Yet Another Opinion That Skins Need A GM
 

[quote=Dogtag;408083]I have been watching the GM debate churn for some time now. It strikes me that debating whether the Redskins should have a GM is rather like debating whether the Federal Government should have income taxes.

Bottom line is that it is not our call (as loyal fans) to make. We may be vested in our interest and support for the team but that is a far as it goes - we don't get a valid vote on this issue.[/quote]

we dont get a vaild note on any issue as fans, and there is no issue that is our call. That is the point of this website.

Re: Yet Another Opinion That Skins Need A GM
 

Snyder said that aspect of the organization is not broken and doesnt need fixed. He is not going to hire a GM and now that he has studied under Gibbs I expect Snyder to become like a defacto GM.

Re: Yet Another Opinion That Skins Need A GM
 

Bobby DePaul would be a great catch if The Danny ever brought on a GM. DePaul is from the area (Bowie, MD), was a Redskins assistant toward the end of Gibbs' first tenure, and has been a personnel guy with the Bears for 6 years now. He's 43 years old, which would be perfect for a GM that could be brought on for the long term.

Re: Yet Another Opinion That Skins Need A GM
 

[QUOTE=skinsnut;408091]Isn't DePaul with the BEARS?
You want a GM from THERE?

Didn't they pay Archuleta's Redskin bonus to get him after he flopped?
What about their QB disaster situation.
I'm not a fan of the Bears moves...
I'm sick of Casserly too...that dude didn't do so well....westbrook?....shuler?

I like the Reese, GWilliams combo idea best[/QUOTE]

Who do you think saved the Redskins money, dah,You can,t blame draft picks by the GM on a pwesonel director , you have know clue to what he really does, may be he does the scouting, salary cap,propersonel, contracts, what has vinny done, what have the bears done, really DePaul should probably go to a team dedicated on winning because dan is not a gm he is just an investor and right now,he s definitely making money regardless of winning, so does he really need to make changes , no,he making money thats why he wont change, if it isnt broke dont fix it

Re: Yet Another Opinion That Skins Need A GM
 

No Because Dan Thinks He Doing Fine Job

Re: Yet Another Opinion That Skins Need A GM
 

There will be no GM. Danny said so already.