Who is more important, Brunell or Moss?

Moss or Brunell?

Discuss

My Pick is brunell. Moss wouldnt have half as many yards if ramsey was our QB. but thats just my opinion.

i am taking the sissy way out. If moss was to get injured we would be done because no one would be there to replace him, if brunell was injured i think we would manage with ramsey

I think patten could fill moss's shoes. I don't know if he'd have all the stats, but he could do his job effectively enough. I dont know now that we have things clicking if one piece here isn't replacable. Not that their not valuble, but they're probably replacable.

I'm going with Brunell. If he goes down, Moss's stats wouldn't be that great. Brunell has a veteran leadership. Ramsey holds the ball too long, and he's not much of a leader when you need him to be. Brunell is cracking jokes in the huddle, lightening up everyone's mood.

we have 4 wide receivers, if moss goes down that is 3 and seeing how patten, thrash and jacobs combine for about 320 total yards i don't see how we could deal without him. Obviously their numbers would go up if moss was gone but moss so far is having one of the best seasons in receiver history.

With that said QB is the most important part of an offense, so i would say Brunell is the "most important".

moss.

I think Brunell is the key cog.

His accuracy, his ability to get rid of the ball quickly, his ability to escape the pocket and make things happen, his ability to read a D and get the ball to the hot receiver, I could go on and on.

Of course Moss has made alot of things happen after the catch, but I think the offense just wouldn't click on the same level if you took Brunell out of the mix.

1 good QB, 1 good WR, they are synergy: 1+1 = 11-5

we had Brunell last year. we didn't have Moss - whose yards are mostly after the catch. draw your own conclusions.

these are different brunells...