Roy Williams illegal or burnt toast?

I really thought the way he dragged Brunell and spun him around should have been roughing the QB.

I really thought the way he dragged Brunell and spun him around should have been roughing the QB.

Their house, their rules.

That's ok, because we got a W!

:dallas: :dallas:

There's no consistency on calls, we always get the shitty end of the stick. I had people watching the Giants game saying "You're kidding, they ain't calling that?" on a couple of plays.

I swear that was a pick on Crayton at the end of the game but they said he didn't have possession. The tackle on Brunell wasn't a horse collar, but close.

We just have to take it out of the Zebra's hands is all.

I really thought the way he dragged Brunell and spun him around should have been roughing the QB.No I'd say he just pulled him down and I'd rather see that than an all out hit on our QB. I don't think that horse collar rule will make it next year. Its just human to grab that area when you are chasing someone from behind and the way they design the jersey's now days its about the only thing to grab.

My point is they've called roughing for a lot less.

Early in the Giants game last night Strahan was chasing Brooks and just gave him a light push from behind, not even a push more like a tap, Brooks went down and they called roughing. It was a pretty lame call.

santana "the human torch" moss just toasted some db's last night

Without much respect to Roy Williams, I am going to be quite blunt. I think the guy is a good player, but a very dirty one at the same time. I think that it was about time that he got a penalty in honor of his horse-collaring and ill regard for clean play. I was appalled at what he got away with last year, and I am glad that the league is finally doing something about it, though they still have to make sure that they follow through on their new rule. I remember how many times he was able to get away doing that to our players last year, tackling from around the collar of guy from their blind side just to gain an edge. It is finally coming around to him now and the guy could not be respected around the NFL very highly for his dirty play. I hope he cleans it up significantly this year, so that his fans can respect him as a player and not a criminal on the field. (The TO example is prime, regardless of my dislike of the Eagles)

Did you listen to Michaels and Madden last night? Whoever the biggest star of the moment is, they're going to spend the whole game blowing. I wonder how much listerine it took to get the taste of Parcells out Madden's gargantuan mouth...

The NFL bends the rules for the stars. Period. The more established you are, the better. It's just like how Jordan never got called for that forearm shiver he used to throw before taking a fade away. Watch an Eagles game and pay attention to how often McNabb is throwing either as he is passing or is already just past the line of scrimmage.

http://www.redskins.com/uploads/photos/perm/main/OHJFKNLBLFGG/redskins_8661125PG.jpg

http://www.redskins.com/uploads/photos/perm/main/OHJFKNLBLFGG/redskins_8661125PG.jpg


Yeah, like that PROVES anything... He could be just patting him on the back... or brushing his shoulders off...