Dyson or McCants?

[QUOTE=scowan]I think this year is it for McCants. If he doesn't step up and make the team, he will be gone from football.[QUOTE]

Atleast he has a backup plan:rolleyes:

Whats his back up plan? To be gone from football.LOL

I think McCant's is more talented and I would like to see him succeed, but after visiting his web page last week I really have some questions about what this guy find's important? I believe it's his mind set or lack of a mind set on football that really put's Gibbs off, but I do believe he is the better player, but he does have his work cut out for him we all know Gibbs would really like to replace him, and if Dyson continues to impress he will.

I think you'd need at least one tall receiver who can out-jump defensive backs in the endzone. But like most others, I need to see more.

Their special teams contributions will be a factor too.

McCants has a future in this league whereas Dyson had a great career. I really think McCants could be used well if Gibbs would suit him up. He's the one receiver Ramsey has had for a long time and they really seem to have a rapport. If he makes your QB confortable that alone is worth something.

Right now, I would probably go with McCants. He did drop some balls in carolina last week but he really is the only big receiver we have. he has showed that he can play and i think he can also add another deep threat. lining up in the slot, he can go down the middle and make those 15-20 yd cathes and take a hit (something he did well in his only real playing time last year against the bengals). dyson is a solid WR but he is injury prone and is getting old. this will definitely be a battle to watch during the rest of preason and i am looking for one of these guys to really show us something as they get a good amount of playing time to make the decision easier.

This is another one that can only be answered if we see these guys with the first team, against the first defense, when we need a possession receiver (like in te endzone).

That means we need to have Ramsey get them into the redzone. Lets hope things start to click on Friday.

mccants still has his right hand in a cast or something from the baltimore scrimmage.

I think it will be Dyson. If I recall, Gibbs never liked McCants because he didn't practice well.

Dyson is too old, Mccants has superior talent, and size. My problem with him is that he never seemed to really care about his lack of playing time...which translates to not caring about his football career.