According to Yahoo The Rookie to watch this season is:

Pages : 1 [2] 3

EternalEnigma21
07-30-2005, 01:14 AM
Lets not get all bent out of shape over something written by Chris Carter. If he was any kind of a talent scout he would't be writing for Yahoo! (an NFL powerhouse authority since...???). From an outsider looking in at this situation, saying things like, "I expect to see Campbell make the biggest impact of any rookie QB" makes sense. We had 2 different starting QBs last year and had a losing record. We have no other QB's other than the 2 we had last year and a rookie that we gave up alot to get.

Rothlesburger was the third QB taken in last years draft and went to a decent team with a great D and had great success. Its a safe bet that SF wont be doing much next year no matter how good their QB play is and Brett Favre's track record indicates that Aaron Rogers won't have much playing time next year. The only way you can say that is if you predict that Brett Favre will get injured in his last year and no one wants to be the dick to predict that...except maybe Javon Walker. lol

Winskins
07-30-2005, 01:18 AM
Alright, we can all answer the question "why did we draft Campbell?"

Quarterbacks get injured!!! If your offensive anchor goes down, your ship is going to stop moving...unless there is something else good in the wings.

skinsfanthru&thru
07-30-2005, 01:25 AM
I don't know if anyone else feels this way, but I think Gibbs is going to give Ramsey a fully legit chance to lead this team. But seeing as to how Gibbs has repeatedly said he's trying to acheive something in the near future, he must have some inkling of faith that if needed, Cambell might be able to step up sooner than most of us would think. Plus even though he hasn't done something before (ie start a rookie qb) doesn't mean squat seeing as to how this year he's implementing several things he hasn't done either at all or very much of in the past. I want to see Cambell through training camp and some preseason action before I pass any judgement one way or another on his possible short term future with the squad.

Redskins8588
07-30-2005, 02:45 AM
I am not sold on the idea that by drafting Campbell is a shot at Ramsey. If anything I would say that it is a shot at Brunell. I remember Gibbs being quoted saying "The most important player on a football team is the quarterback, the second most important player is the second string quarterback." So, if that is true I dont think that Gibbs would give Ramsey the job if he wasnt ready. Also, I think that shows that he really doesnt believe that Brunell has anything left. Just my thoughts...

offiss
07-30-2005, 01:56 PM
Let Ramsey Play All 16 Games Then We Will Talk About Cambell


No fooling.


Ramsey was entering his third year in the NFL and his intelligence is at genious level, and even by the end of the year he still hadn't become fully comfortable in with the understanding of Gibbs offense, and we are to believe Campbell is the kid to watch? A rookie coming in is going to succeed in Gibbs offense? a lot of these articles I am convinced are written by people who don't know a thing about sports or football, they don't have the ability to discern that certain situations can affect a QB's performance, a lot of these guy's just want to brush Ramsey aside because Gibbs keeps trading for other QB's, maybe Gibbs himself doesn't yet understand what he has in Ramsey but the kid is going to be outstanding this season if Gibbs can just coach on an average level, and if the Gibbs of old shows up Ramsey could very well vie for an MVP.

SKINSnCANES
07-30-2005, 11:53 PM
Gibbs would not have traded for a first round pick, and also drafted Campbell if he didnt think he was the QB that would work in his system and not Ramsey. With that being said, Ramsey is the guy for this year, atleast the start of it. But dont coutn on Ramsey getting a contract extension even if he has a great year.

SmootSmack
07-31-2005, 03:35 AM
Ramsey was entering his third year in the NFL and his intelligence is at genious level.

Just wondering, what was Ramsey's Wonderlic score?

SmootSmack
07-31-2005, 03:41 AM
Nevermind, I got it 32 (http://www.macmirabile.com/Wonderlic/Wonderlic.htm)

EternalEnigma21
07-31-2005, 01:55 PM
With all the skeptisism surrounding Jason Campbells low scores here are some things to consider:
McNabb, Donovan 1999 Syracuse 16, 12

Culpepper, Daunte 1999 Central Fla. 18, 21, 15

Marino, Dan 1983 Pittsburgh 14

Cunningham, Randall 1985 UNLV 15

McNair, Steve 1995 Alcorn State 15

And for those of you actually getting excited right now, here's your reality check....






Shuler, Heath 1994 Tennessee 16

SmootSmack
07-31-2005, 02:00 PM
Not to mention Jason Maas and Todd Husak each 43.

EZ Archive Ads Plugin for vBulletin Copyright 2006 Computer Help Forum