BigSKINBauer
07-14-2005, 05:44 AM
I got this from another fan site, the writer said he goes to the EA HQ and says he copied down the overall ratings, here is the link http://extremeskins.com/forums/showthread.php?s=&threadid=105947
Ramsey 83
Brunell 80
Campbell 78
Portis 92
Betts 78
Cartwright 76
Sellers 80
Moss 87
Gardner 84
Patten 82
Jacobs 76
McCants 74
Thrash 73
Cooley 79
Royal 76
baber 62
Samuels 92
Molinaro 63
R. Brown 80
Doclery 75
Rabach 85
Raymer 80
R. Thomas 92
Albright 50
Jansen 91
M. Wilson 64
R. Wynn 81
Boschetti 60
Daniels 83
D. Evans 69
Griffin 88
Noble 78
Salave'a 71
M. Washington 92
Clemons 73
K. Campbell 62
Barrow 85
L. Marshall 80
R. McCune 68
Arrington 95
Holdman 86
B. Allen 71
Springs 87
Harris 81
Rogers 80
Wilds 70
Jimoh 64
S. Taylor 91
Prioleau 85
Lott 71
Bowen 83
Clark 78
Hall 81
Tupa 87
BigSKINBauer
07-14-2005, 05:48 AM
THRASH A 73, I THINK THAT I SHOULD SLAP MADDEN IN ALL OF HIS JIGGLY FACE. COOOOOOOOLEY 79 and SPRINGS AN 87 and GRIFFIN A 88.
There is a beating to be had
Only person who got more credit than deserved........ BRUNNEL. a bitter slap in the face.
I like Marcus's rating though and TAYLOR and Arrington's, he fell but thats ok, O-line is kickin but DOCKERY! is skrewd.
joecrisp
07-14-2005, 06:06 AM
These guys are clueless about Salave'a. He's incredibly underrated on that game with a 71. He should at least be even with Noble, and should probably be around 80. The guy's much more athletic than they give him credit for.
I've always wondered how they come up with these ratings. Do they actually watch film and dissect each player's performance and skills or what? It seems to me it's mostly name power. I always wind up having to tweak the ratings when I buy the game, and not just for the Redskins.
Brunell is an 80 on name alone. The first move I do when I get the game will be to ship his ass out.
I generally agree with these ratings. If you go by these ratings the Skins seem to have a pretty solid team this year.
I've heard that they do some pretty extensive research on each player, but in the end it all comes down to somebody's subjective opinion.
SmootSmack
07-14-2005, 10:10 AM
Is Prioleau really our 2nd best safety? I had no idea he was that good
Wow I just noticed Campbell with a 78, pretty good for a rook.
Raymer looks a tad overrated, I would knock him down to the 70-75 range. He's really not starting quality anymore.
Sheriff Gonna Getcha
07-14-2005, 08:00 PM
Here is how I'd rate the Redskins:
Ramsey 83
Brunell 74
Campbell 75
Portis 94
Betts 78
Cartwright 76
Sellers 74
Moss 86
Gardner 83
Patten 85
Jacobs 76
McCants 74
Thrash 78
Cooley 85
Royal 74
baber 62
Samuels 94
Molinaro 63
R. Brown 83
Doclery 79
Rabach 85
Raymer 74
R. Thomas 92
Albright 50
Jansen 95
M. Wilson 64
R. Wynn 78
Boschetti 60
Daniels 80
D. Evans 73
Griffin 92
Noble 75
Salave'a 81
M. Washington 93
Clemons 74
K. Campbell 62
Barrow 85
L. Marshall 82
R. McCune 70
Arrington 94
Holdman 86
B. Allen 71
Springs 94
Harris 83
Rogers 80
Wilds 72
Jimoh 64
S. Taylor 91
Prioleau 82
Lott 73
Bowen 81
Clark 83
Hall 84
Tupa 90
Sheriff Gonna Getcha
07-14-2005, 08:02 PM
Is Prioleau really our 2nd best safety? I had no idea he was that good
He's supposedly decent. I'd probably put him around 82 on a Madden scale. I personally think that Clark is better (as he's more versatile) than Bowen or Pierson and is our 2nd best safety.
Riggo44
07-14-2005, 09:42 PM
I think after last season these ratings aren't that bad. When does Madden 2006 come out anyway?
madisonwm
07-15-2005, 02:09 AM
Here is how I'd rate the Redskins:
Ramsey 83
Brunell 74
Campbell 75
Portis 94
Betts 78
Cartwright 76
Sellers 74
Moss 86
Gardner 83
Patten 85
Jacobs 76
McCants 74
Thrash 78
Cooley 85
Royal 74
baber 62
Samuels 94
Molinaro 63
R. Brown 83
Doclery 79
Rabach 85
Raymer 74
R. Thomas 92
Albright 50
Jansen 95
M. Wilson 64
R. Wynn 78
Boschetti 60
Daniels 80
D. Evans 73
Griffin 92
Noble 75
Salave'a 81
M. Washington 93
Clemons 74
K. Campbell 62
Barrow 85
L. Marshall 82
R. McCune 70
Arrington 94
Holdman 86
B. Allen 71
Springs 94
Harris 83
Rogers 80
Wilds 72
Jimoh 64
S. Taylor 91
Prioleau 82
Lott 73
Bowen 81
Clark 83
Hall 84
Tupa 90
jansen higher than samuels.... no way.....not even if he was 100% all of last year... Jansen wishes he could be Samuels....