SunnySide
01-09-2023, 02:34 PM
Option 1 makes my stomach turn and head spin. Lol
Option 2 is risky anytime but more-so when there isn’t a bonafide stud. Which is this year. Also what are we giving up to take that risk?
That imo leaves Option 3. Roll with Sam. I just disagree with him being our quarterback and seeing the same results or even worse (1 game under .500) that we did this year. The fact that you think he wouldn’t be a better option than Taylor, or even Wentz is questionable to say the least. We “should” have a better D next year if we address LB and CB. Young will be fully healthy. We certainly “should” still have our RB’s and WR’s intact. See to me the question isn’t Sam as much as it is who is calling the shots when it comes to personnel. Who is calling the plays? Who is the HC? But even if we ran it back with this same exact team and staff ( [emoji2961] ) I see Sam as an upgrade. Imo if Sam came in for that first Giants game and played the last month our season would not be over.
Option 1 is the only path to the playoffs next year
Option 2 is the only path to potential long term playoff contender/SB contender
Option 3 is digestible but most likely its just a car ride in a circle and we end back here in mediocrity purgatory at this same time next year wondering what to do with our 16th overall pick
--
It is what it is.
We have no control or say so.
I will cheer for whoever is under center.
With this team .. its doesnt matter.
until we land a stud QB1 ... its all the same shit, different year.
sdskinsfan2001
01-09-2023, 02:37 PM
Option 1 is the only path to the playoffs next year
Option 2 is the only path to potential long term playoff contender/SB contender
Option 3 is digestible but most likely its just a car ride in a circle and we end back here in mediocrity purgatory at this same time next year wondering what to do with our 16th overall pick
--
It is what it is.
We have no control or say so.
I will cheer for whoever is under center.
With this team .. its doesnt matter.
until we land a stud QB1 ... its all the same shit, different year.
We were 1 win away from the playoffs this year with Heinicke and Wentz.
Howell will be better than both of them next year. We can absolutely make the playoffs with Howell as our QB.
punch it in
01-09-2023, 02:39 PM
Option 1 is the only path to the playoffs next year
Option 2 is the only path to potential long term playoff contender/SB contender
Option 3 is digestible but most likely its just a car ride in a circle and we end back here in mediocrity purgatory at this same time next year wondering what to do with our 16th overall pick
--
It is what it is.
We have no control or say so.
I will cheer for whoever is under center.
With this team .. its doesnt matter.
until we land a stud QB1 ... its all the same shit, different year.
We we’re pretty damn close to the playoffs this year SS. Slightly better quarterback play would’ve got us there. I don’t think it is as doom and gloom as usual when the season is over but who knows? Competent staff and a new owner would br a great start. Howell may surprise us but we need the right people around him. See the 49’ers.
BaltimoreSkins
01-09-2023, 02:40 PM
Interesting article from 2021 that looks at trading up for "your guy" It had been done 29 times in the common draft era with mixed results.
https://www.espn.com/nfl/draft2021/story/_/id/31173355/all-29-s-nfl-teams-traded-draft-quarterback
I don't want to do a king's ransom for a guy because that gamble rarely seems to work but a modest trade up if we think we can get a first round grade prospect I'd be for it.
SFREDSKIN
01-09-2023, 02:46 PM
Interesting article from 2021 that looks at trading up for "your guy" It had been done 29 times in the common draft era with mixed results.
https://www.espn.com/nfl/draft2021/story/_/id/31173355/all-29-s-nfl-teams-traded-draft-quarterback
I don't want to do a king's ransom for a guy because that gamble rarely seems to work but a modest trade up if we think we can get a first round grade prospect I'd be for it.
Mixed results? Mainly bad to terrible results.
We we’re pretty damn close to the playoffs this year SS. Slightly better quarterback play would’ve got us there. I don’t think it is as doom and gloom as usual when the season is over but who knows? Competent staff and a new owner would br a great start. Howell may surprise us but we need the right people around him. See the 49’ers.
Better decision making in the titans and vikings games also get us there...
see the ridiculous games vs. the giants, as well.
EARTHQUAKE2689
01-09-2023, 02:48 PM
Better than going in with Wentz and Taylor and they got us 7 wins. Howell is better than either guy. If he played for the last few weeks our season isn’t over.
Wouldn't go in with them either
mredskins
01-09-2023, 02:53 PM
Interesting article from 2021 that looks at trading up for "your guy" It had been done 29 times in the common draft era with mixed results.
https://www.espn.com/nfl/draft2021/story/_/id/31173355/all-29-s-nfl-teams-traded-draft-quarterback
I don't want to do a king's ransom for a guy because that gamble rarely seems to work but a modest trade up if we think we can get a first round grade prospect I'd be for it.
i wonder if they write a code that goes back in past articles and wipes Redskins/WFT logos and replaces it with Commanders logo.
Ruhskins
01-09-2023, 02:57 PM
Andrew Brandt always talks about the conflict between the front office (planning for the future) vs coaching staff (planning for now). With new ownership and Snyder's f*ckery out of the way, I'm curious to see some of that in play next year.
While a new owner won't make changes right away, I'm sure there will be some push back on making a big trade, either up in the draft or for a veteran, this offseason. I guess this would depend on the timeline of when a new owner can take charge of the team and when free agency/the draft happens.
BaltimoreSkins
01-09-2023, 03:22 PM
i wonder if they write a code that goes back in past articles and wipes Redskins/WFT logos and replaces it with Commanders logo.
Hahaha that's funny I didn't even notice that the first time I went through