KI Skins Fan
08-29-2022, 10:04 AM
I think I agree, but RR did bump Robinson up ahead of Gibson. I think there is probably plenty of time to worry about QB -2 with Wentz here though. In other words I hope neither Howell or Heinicke see the field at all this year.
You can hope for it but don't bet on it. And if a QB change is made it won't necessarily be due to an injury to Wentz. This season Wentz's entire career is at risk if he doesn't perform well. That's a lot of pressure to bear and I'm not yet convinced that he can handle it. You see, I think his issues at Philly and Indy might have been for the most part emotional.
Wentz has all the skills and athleticism to be a top QB if he can handle the pressure. Maybe he will and maybe he won't
punch it in
08-29-2022, 10:08 AM
You can hope for it but don't bet on it. And if a QB change is made it won't necessarily be due to an injury to Wentz. This season Wentz's entire career is at risk if he doesn't perform well. That's a lot of pressure to bear and I'm not yet convinced that he can handle it. You see, I think his issues at Philly and Indy might have been for the most part emotional.
Wentz has all the skills and athleticism to be a top QB if he can handle the pressure. Maybe he will and maybe he won't
I don’t doubt this could be the case at all whatsoever lol
SunnySide
08-29-2022, 11:52 AM
Howell blows Heinicke away. Its no surprise that a dinosaur like Ron would choose not to make him the backup just because he's a rookie. Its time to move on from Heinicke.
Howell has looked good, throwing some strong down field outs and other throws Heinike cant make.
That said, I just assume our week 1 QB will be injured at some point and I dont think you can throw Howell out there as a 5th round rookie (but good college seasoning).
We most likely going to carry 3 QBs ... as we should every season imo. You should always have a mid late round rookie QB on there to develop and see if you struck gold.
irish
08-29-2022, 11:58 AM
Agree [emoji817]- if Wentz goes down for an extended amount of time and the season seems out if reach then get Howell the experience but if Wentz is out for a limited time and the season is still in play let TH roll.
I don't see why Howell cant spot play as easily as Heinicke can. Hopefully Wentz goes the distance but IMO the Heinicke thing has run its course.
Chief X_Phackter
08-29-2022, 01:52 PM
The question for me is, does Howell's arm strength trump Heinicke's NFL experience, and his experience in this system? I don't think it does. So if we're talking about winning, I think that right now, if Wentz went down you would have to go to Heinicke.
Maybe as the season progresses, so does Howell - to the point where he gives the team a better chance to win than Heinicke. But if we're talking about right now, I don't think we're there.
sdskinsfan2001
08-29-2022, 02:00 PM
Howell is better than Heinicke. Whoever is better should be No. 2 imo.
Chief X_Phackter
08-29-2022, 02:05 PM
He may have a better skill set, but that doesn't mean he is ready for any team's starting defense.
If they name him #2, I'll be on board and trust that the Coaches know what they are doing. If they name him #3 - same.
sdskinsfan2001
08-29-2022, 02:08 PM
He may have a better skill set, but that doesn't mean he is ready for any team's starting defense.
If they name him #2, I'll be on board and trust that the Coaches know what they are doing. If they name him #3 - same.
Yeah, this isn't a big deal either way IMO. I think it's a toss-up between the 2, I just think Howell would be better. But either one would be a significant drop-off from a healthy Wentz. So hopefully Wentz can play all 17.
We've seen the preseason heroes come and go especially at QB. I like Howell but we need to slow down a bit. Heinicke brings value as a backup and he's a great guy to have in the QB room.
sdskinsfan2001
08-29-2022, 02:10 PM
We've seen the preseason heroes come and go especially at QB. I like Howell but we need to slow down a bit. Heinicke brings value as a backup and he's a great guy to have in the QB room.
I think we need to keep all 3 on the active roster (I think Sunny said the same earlier, so I agree w/ his point).
I don't think Howell or Heinicke would make it through waivers to get back to P.S. (not even sure if Henicke is eligible for P.S. either).