Rank the Skins 1st Round Picks Since 2000

1) Chris Samuels
2) Sean Taylor
3) Trent Williams
4) Ryan Kerrigan
5) Brandon Scherff
6) Jonathan Allen
7) Robert Griffin III
8) Carlos Rogers
9) Brian Orakpo
10) Lavar Arrington
11) Jason Campbell
12) LaRon Landry
13) Patrick Ramsey
14) Rod Gardner
15) Josh Doctson

Like many others, I also think it is too soon for Haskins, Sweat, and Payne.

1) Samuels
2) Silverback
3) Kerrigan
4) Sean Taylor
5) Orakpo

My top 5

I wonder what could have been with RG3 if he and the Redskins did things differently. Meddling Snyder making him his favorite son, Shanny letting him play when injured, and Robert's own reckless play contributed to a quick down fall.

Good point. How much different would the Redskins have been if Mike Shanahan would've had the deal that Rivera has now, and Snyder didn't "mingle" with his favorite players.

I'll do it a little differently and just group them

Studs:
Taylor
Williams
Samuels
Scherff
Kerrigan

Solid:
Arrington
Allen
Payne
Landry
Rogers
Orakpo

Duds or Busts:
Campbell
Ramsey
Doctson
Gardner
RG3

TBD:
Sweat
Haskins

i think the worst possible first 3 picks ever was Devin Thomas, Malcolm Kelly and whoeve rthe hell that tight end was from usc .... three straight picks with Desean Jackson also on the boards for two of them i believe. Smh Vinny, Smh

The amount of total draft-busts in this list is just depressing. But you have to remember Bruce Allen and Vinny Cerrato we’re making the draft choices. The real poll is to vote on who was worse: Allen or Cerrato? [] Both were terrible GMs who couldn’t even get real starters even with first round draft choices!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

That's like asking: would you rather drown or burn to death?

[quote=skinsfaninok;1245804]1) Trent Williams
2) Chris Samuels
3) Sean Taylor
4) RK
5) Brandon Scherff
6) RG3
7) RAK
8) ALLEN
9) Carlos Rogers
10) Lavar Arrington
11) Jason Campbell
12) LaRon Landry
13) Patrick Ramsey
14) Rod Gardner
15) Josh Doctson[







RG3 cost 3 FIRST Round picks and played less than 3 full seasons. It is crazy to put him in the top 6 picks.

http://www.nfl.com/player/robertgrffiniii/2533033/careerstats

[quote=skinsfaninok;1245804]1) Trent Williams
2) Chris Samuels
3) Sean Taylor
4) RK
5) Brandon Scherff
6) RG3
7) RAK
8) ALLEN
9) Carlos Rogers
10) Lavar Arrington
11) Jason Campbell
12) LaRon Landry
13) Patrick Ramsey
14) Rod Gardner
15) Josh Doctson[







RG3 cost 3 FIRST Round picks and played less than 3 full seasons. It is crazy to put him in the top 6 picks.

http://www.nfl.com/player/robertgrffiniii/2533033/careerstats

His impact was as big as almost any of these guys on the list

[quote=skinsfaninok;1245804]1) Trent Williams

2) Chris Samuels

3) Sean Taylor

4) RK

5) Brandon Scherff

6) RG3

7) RAK

8) ALLEN

9) Carlos Rogers

10) Lavar Arrington

11) Jason Campbell

12) LaRon Landry

13) Patrick Ramsey

14) Rod Gardner

15) Josh Doctson[















RG3 cost 3 FIRST Round picks and played less than 3 full seasons. It is crazy to put him in the top 6 picks.



http://www.nfl.com/player/robertgrffiniii/2533033/careerstats



I like putting Doctson in the cellar. I can’t understand why Bruce Allen kept Doctson while letting Garçon, DJax and Crowder all walk.

I think RG3 needs to be lower. He only had one excellent season (rookie) and then went downhill rapidly.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk