Battle of the bad GM's

Both are plain horse shit. Allen still having a job is completely unacceptable. He has fucked the QB position up from day 1.

I voted Allen. That RG3 trade set us back multiple years, as did the Kirk deal. His deals have had longer lasting implications, setting us back more years.

Sean Taylor died on Vinny's watch.

Vinny declared war on the fans. Bruce never did that. So i voted for Vinny.

To answer the question seriously, I think Allen's method of team building is more likely to result in sustained contention. Vinny went out and whiffed on too many big money free agents and we traded away too many valuable draft picks. Some of that was on Joe Gibbs though if we're being completely honest, the same way the RGIII trade was on Shanahan (remember, they both had final say on roster moves and trades at that time).

But Allen has adopted McCloughan's approach to building through the draft and letting marginal free agents walk for overpriced contracts, turning them into compensatory selections.

That's the formula Bill Belichick uses, except he knows how to coach and how to pick players. Allen at least has the right formula, with none of the know-how. Vinny had nothing at all.

Vinny struck out swinging for the fences.
Bruce's objective is mediocrity.

Vinny brought in high priced free agents to fill voids on the team hoping they would push us into the playoffs.
Bruce creates voids and fills them if the $1 store version of their replacement( Garcon/Jackson - Pryor/Richardson).

I give the edge to Vinny and his better record.

Oh whoops, looked like I dropped this "Fire Bruce Allen" petition here. Guess I should pick this back up and stick it in my pocket...

https://www.change.org/p/redskins-need-to-fire-bruce-allen/psf/promote_or_share

Vinny’s w/l record is propped up a bit by Gibbs 2.0 so I don’t put too much stock in that


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

There is no right or wrong answer here. Those ass clowns are probably 2 of the worst executives in all of pro sports in the last 30 years. Go Skins lol.

Kirk cousins 4-24 record or w.ever when playing winning teams doesn't even make me feel bad... Malcom Kelly and Devin Thomas picked before DJax.... All the aging bad money signings on VC... But.... Fuckboth I vote 'indie'