Trade Deadline Moves

Is Collins next??

No , he is one of the young ones they want to build around like Odell and Barkley.

I LOVE the way Collins plays. What would you trade to get him?

Me, no less than a #1 but that's me.He is up for a new contract after this season.

I'm glad there isn't a Franchise QB available in the next draft class.
We get to see the Giants tank for at least 2 seasons!

There wasn't one in this class,not that I have seen yet.

There wasn't one in this class,not that I have seen yet.

You're kidding right

You're kidding right

No , I do like the kid the Giants picked up from Richmond. Were there some good young ones yes but no I have not seen a franchise one out of any of them....yet. The Barkley pick was the right move as much as you don't like it I can see why they did it now.

Mayfield and Darnold are both playing well as rookies, not sure what you're missing there.

By the time the Giants are relevant again Barkley will be nearing his 2nd contract. The only reason they took him over a QB is they thought they could win now with Eli. Clearly a huge miscalculation.

Mayfield and Darnold are both playing well as rookies, not sure what you're missing there.

By the time the Giants are relevant again Barkley will be nearing his 2nd contract. The only reason they took him over a QB is they thought they could win now with Eli. Clearly a huge miscalculation.

Darnold and Mayfield are playing Ok no way I am putting them in the HOF yet , we will agree to disagree on the rest. Eli threw for almost 4 hundred the other night and no INT's ...it's not on Eli.

Mayfield and Darnold are both playing well as rookies, not sure what you're missing there.

By the time the Giants are relevant again Barkley will be nearing his 2nd contract. The only reason they took him over a QB is they thought they could win now with Eli. Clearly a huge miscalculation.

Darnold looks really good imo. Baker needs to chill the f out, once he does he should be legit.

Darnold looks really good imo. Baker needs to chill the f out, once he does he should be legit.

Why I used the word yet. Redskin fans should know as well as anyone that a good even great first year for a rookie QB doesn't mean a thing . Continued success and growth in year two then I might proclaim a "franchise QB".

Mayfield and Darnold are both playing well as rookies, not sure what you're missing there.

By the time the Giants are relevant again Barkley will be nearing his 2nd contract. The only reason they took him over a QB is they thought they could win now with Eli. Clearly a huge miscalculation.


What is your definition of "playing well".

http://www.espn.com/nfl/player/stats/_/id/3052587/baker-mayfield

http://www.espn.com/nfl/player/_/id/3912547/sam-darnold


He's got way too many turnovers and is sporting a below 80 rating.


Granted, I think he's(BM) giving the Browns a chance to win the games unlike that trashcan Tyrod Taylor.

Same with Darnold too. I get these guys are rookies, but I wouldn't say they are "playing well". They are playing as expected in my opinion. Lots of turnovers and inconsistencies.