Week 13

Eli was terrible the other night but benching him for Geno is an embarrassment. McADoof is a joke.

I can't believe McAdoo is just giving a great big FU to the players, fans and management. Sure, the Giants suck. Yes, Manning's best days (such as they were) are behind him ... but, geez, Geno Smith?? I mean, he has to realize how idiotic this move is. Why isn't this just coaching suicide for McAdoo? Who hires him after a crap move like this?

Words really do fail me.

I can't believe McAdoo is just giving a great big FU to the players, fans and management. Sure, the Giants suck. Yes, Manning's best days (such as they were) are behind him ... but, geez, Geno Smith?? I mean, he has to realize how idiotic this move is. Why isn't this just coaching suicide for McAdoo? Who hires him after a crap move like this?

Words really do fail me.

No kidding. If you are going to evaluate the roster for the future you put the rookie Webb in, not Geno Smith. With Geno Smith you know what you have a career back-up that would be third string on a lot of teams. Major slap in a two time SB winner's face and a pathetic move by the Giants. I think 99% of the NFL fan base think Eli got a raw deal.

I can't believe McAdoo is just giving a great big FU to the players, fans and management. Sure, the Giants suck. Yes, Manning's best days (such as they were) are behind him ... but, geez, Geno Smith?? I mean, he has to realize how idiotic this move is. Why isn't this just coaching suicide for McAdoo? Who hires him after a crap move like this?

Words really do fail me.

As always some things are starting to come out and it seems while Mara did approve the "we will play the others a bit thing" he didn't want Eli benched and it's Eli who is saying fuck this.Now Mara has no idea how to come back from it,they weren't expecting Eli to say no to part time,they under estimated him again.

No kidding. If you are going to evaluate the roster for the future you put the rookie Webb in, not Geno Smith. With Geno Smith you know what you have a career back-up that would be third string on a lot of teams. Major slap in a two time SB winner's face and a pathetic move by the Giants. I think 99% of the NFL fan base think Eli got a raw deal.

That's the point why Smith and not Webb? Rumor that Collins, DRC and JPP and Vernon all went to Spags and had a fit about the whole mess,Eli just isn't the leader he is the Offensive Captain of the team seems mcAdoo didn't want to deal with the D.

I hate the Giants and Eli Manning more than anything but now I am an Eli fan. I certainly always respected the guy (even though Tuck and the D deserved the mvp in his first victory and D again in the second) which is more than I can say for his owner, coach, or GM. Reese and Mcadont are clowns. There is just no reason for this move. Let the guy finish out his year. Season has been over, and who the fuck are they kidding with Smith? U wanna get a look at what he has got? This is one of the biggest slaps in the face in sports history. I would be absolutely ashamed to call myself a fan of that organization. Sorry Giant One.

Eli's playing like shit and frankly he deserved to be benched. I could not believe how bad he stunk last week. But to be benched for Geno Smith? Smith is a garbage man.



Giants are cleaning house after the season's over. Reece is gone and so is their HC.



Eli has certainly not risen above his obstacles. Which are alot. Like no coach or players anywhere around him on offense. But so what? Season is over and the guy has been more than a warrior for his entire career. Never a single issue on or off the field except his awww shucks face. If the Giants were still alive, and there was a quarterback with potential- and Eli was throwing balls in the dirt and high like he did last week - well than by all means. At the end of the day it is about the team not any one player. But the Giants are dead. You let Eli finish out like a warrior should. Disgraceful move by the clowns running that team.

you know what, fuck the giants.

I can't believe McAdoo is just giving a great big FU to the players, fans and management. Sure, the Giants suck. Yes, Manning's best days (such as they were) are behind him ... but, geez, Geno Smith?? I mean, he has to realize how idiotic this move is. Why isn't this just coaching suicide for McAdoo? Who hires him after a crap move like this?

Words really do fail me.

This move came off to me much the same way Zorn's fake FG in the MNF game against the Giants. Both guys finding some way to say to Ownership, sure fire me, but I just gave you a big fat turd sandwich.

Gotta root for Philly this week :vomit:

we need seattle to start losing and atlanta or carolina