Round 2 Nfl playoffs.

I would take Wilson over both. So far Cam is a one season wonder, and Luck is good but not great.

Randall Cunningham may not be in the top 20 of all time, but he was top 10 in his era. He was the first dynamic running QB.

I like Wilson a lot, but this is the first season that his team solely depended on his passing play to win games.

I think Wilson and Newton will continue their successes from this season. I think Luck could be there in that conversation, depending on how he rebounds from this season.

I would take Wilson over both. So far Cam is a one season wonder, and Luck is good but not great.

Randall Cunningham may not be in the top 20 of all time, but he was top 10 in his era. He was the first dynamic running QB.


No that was Fran Tarkenton.


https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fran_Tarkenton

One season wonder??? Are we watching the same Cam??

I think I am watching the same Cam. Before this year, 59.4 perfect completion rate 82 TD and 54 Int. Plus 27 fumbles with 11 lost. I know I am not taking into consideration his rushing numbers, but as a passer, he was average at best.

This is why i said, one season wonder.

He was the ROY and went to two pro bowls before this one. He may be having his best year, and has shown he can be an effective passer from the pocket over the long haul, but to call him a one year wonder is a wee bit silly. I would take him over Wilson in a heartbeat.


RG3 and Eddie Lacey were AP Offensive Rookies of the year. That means nothing.

Please define effective passer from the pocket. We may have a different definition. To me, before this year, his passing numbers we average at best. 59.4 perfect completion rate 82 TD and 54 Int.

No that was Fran Tarkenton.


https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fran_Tarkenton

He was the first dynamic running QB in the modern era??

My Top 5, 10.
1-5 (in no particular order): Unitas, Graham, Montana, Brady, Elway
6-10 (again, in no particular order): Manning, Marino, Bobby Lane, Baugh, Kelly.

If you bump Manning into to the top five, not sure who you would bump out an argument could be made for each. Just outside my top 10, although again, certainly an argument could be made to include them: W. Moon and D. Brees.

How can you not include Elway in your top 10?

How can you not include Elway in your top 10?

I don't want to appear like I'm picking on you but:



My Top 5, 10.
1-5 (in no particular order): Unitas, Graham, Montana, Brady, Elway
6-10 (again, in no particular order): Manning, Marino, Bobby Lane, Baugh, Kelly.

My Top 5, 10.
1-5 (in no particular order): Unitas, Graham, Montana, Brady, Elway
6-10 (again, in no particular order): Manning, Marino, Bobby Lane, Baugh, Kelly.


seems like a pretty solid list.

Vernon Davis continues to be a non-factor in Denver | ProFootballTalk (http://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com/2016/01/19/vernon-davis-continues-to-be-a-non-factor-in-denver/)

Remember when folks here wanted this chump?

He was the first dynamic running QB in the modern era??


yes.