punch it in
01-19-2016, 01:03 AM
John Taylor and Jerry Rice didn't come till 1985 and 1986. Montana like Brady made his average receivers better. By 1984 Joe had won 2 SB's, their best draft was in 1986.
Still had great teams n a great coach.
As Ive said he is a great QB. Put him anywhere from 1-10 on your list n i wont think twice about it, but I can think of 5 i would take before him if I were starting a team tomorrow.
SFREDSKIN
01-19-2016, 01:05 AM
Still had great teams n a great coach.
As Ive said he is a great QB. Put him anywhere from 1-10 on your list n i wont think twice about it, but I can think of 5 i would take before him if I were starting a team tomorrow.
You are crazy, Montana or Brady for me, currently Andrew Luck.
punch it in
01-19-2016, 07:40 AM
You are crazy, Montana or Brady for me, currently Andrew Luck.
All three with ties to the West Coast? Hmmmm. Who is your fourth choice? Todd Marinovich? [emoji41]
Chico23231
01-19-2016, 10:28 AM
1. Manning
1 a. Brady
2. Horse tooth jackass
2a Montana
3. Marino
punch it in
01-19-2016, 11:01 AM
1. Manning
1 a. Brady
2. Horse tooth jackass
2a Montana
3. Marino
http://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20160119/b19afcee6a77c587f2625aa398d009ae.jpg
donofriose
01-19-2016, 12:18 PM
You are crazy, Montana or Brady for me, currently Andrew Luck.
I would take Cam Newton over Luck.
OmahaRedskins
01-19-2016, 12:39 PM
I would take Cam Newton over Luck.
I would take Wilson over both. So far Cam is a one season wonder, and Luck is good but not great.
Randall Cunningham may not be in the top 20 of all time, but he was top 10 in his era. He was the first dynamic running QB.
JoeRedskin
01-19-2016, 01:44 PM
I would take Cam Newton over Luck.
In a heart beat. Newton has really grown as a QB in the NFL. I know Luck was dealing with injuries last year but I just wasn't seeing growth as a passer. He came in head and shoulders above the rest of his class in terms of NFL readiness but both Wilson and Newton (I know, not his class but close enough) have progressed further (yes, they had further to go). I would not be surprised if Luck as good as he can be at this point. A good QB who throws lots of TD's and INT's.
I would not be surprised if, in ten years, we look back on Newton, Luck, & Wilson and determine that Newton and Wilson's career acheivements far surpassed Luck's.
Of the rest from 2012(Griffin, Cousins, Foles, Tannehill, Weeden, & Oswhieler), only Cousins has shown any real growth and then only over the 10 games of the regular season. However, if he continues on this career trajectory, he too could ultimately surpass Luck.
As for the greatest of all time QB's, well, I break it into top 5, top 10 and I think Manning certainly is in the first conversation and a must in the second.
My Top 5, 10.
1-5 (in no particular order): Unitas, Graham, Montana, Brady, Elway
6-10 (again, in no particular order): Manning, Marino, Bobby Lane, Baugh, Kelly.
If you bump Manning into to the top five, not sure who you would bump out an argument could be made for each. Just outside my top 10, although again, certainly an argument could be made to include them: W. Moon and D. Brees.
EARTHQUAKE2689
01-19-2016, 02:38 PM
I would take Wilson over both. So far Cam is a one season wonder, and Luck is good but not great.
Randall Cunningham may not be in the top 20 of all time, but he was top 10 in his era. He was the first dynamic running QB.
One season wonder??? Are we watching the same Cam??
punch it in
01-19-2016, 03:31 PM
I would take Wilson over both. So far Cam is a one season wonder, and Luck is good but not great.
Randall Cunningham may not be in the top 20 of all time, but he was top 10 in his era. He was the first dynamic running QB.
He was the ROY and went to two pro bowls before this one. He may be having his best year, and has shown he can be an effective passer from the pocket over the long haul, but to call him a one year wonder is a wee bit silly. I would take him over Wilson in a heartbeat.