DCopper04
03-22-2005, 03:31 PM
Keep the rule as it is now. Put three refs up in the booth who have the ability to view replay. If the on-field ref screws up, the booth refs have the authority to overturn the call on the field. Unanimous vote required to overturn a call. This would work for all calls, not just PI calls.
Daseal
03-22-2005, 04:08 PM
DCooper: The problem I see with that particular scenario is how long do you normally have before the next play is run? 30 seconds maybe? That's a lot to do in 30 seconds. Three people see a review, agree, overturn, page ref all within a 30 second period? That's tough to do!
BigSKINBauer
03-22-2005, 04:11 PM
Ok it is an upgrade IF there is the judgement thing b/c at least if the two down field just get tangled up there wont be no 45 yard penalty but w/o it i am sure we would see ALOT of PI not to give up a big play
THERE also should be challanges on PI plays and other penalties b/c it skrews everything up. I mean i understand why fumbles that are called incomplete passes can't be challenged but PI seems to me like nothing could go wrong the play would continue if the ball was caught and ran in for a touchdown it doesn't stop like in a case of a dropped ball
This is somewhat benificial for the defense for a change
THEY SHOULD CHANGE OVERTIME RULES BEFORE ANYTHING!!!
CrazyCanuck
03-22-2005, 04:55 PM
The PI calls need to be fixed so I'm all for any improvement, whether it's 15-yarders or allowing teams to challenge. I'm sick of the inconsistent PI calls I see every game, especially when we're the ones who get burnt most of the time.
TheMalcolmConnection
03-22-2005, 05:06 PM
Anyone have any stats on the team with the most defensive PI calls?