Who's your pick's for next HC, DC and OC?

If another coach, you think 2009 was a playoff team?

You know, you really got me thinking about the context of 2009 defense and Ill probably more inclined to agree than before. Its not just RG3, but I think the top end talent on the Offense is head and shoulders above, I really strongly believe that. I really think we add 2 WR to this team and back to wow factor quickly. Easier said than done.

I think the most disappointing thing is you made me think about our Dline...really underachieving imo. Thats a good point.

Tripp do you not think Garcon is as good as I do? Last year when he played we won. When he didnt we lost. This year he is aces. I agree with your assessment of 09 vs 13 minus two things. JAson Campbell sucked. I cant even mention him in the same breath as Griff. Also our wr core is better now solely due to Garcon. Dude is a stud.

Contracts matter, you're right. We had two albatross contracts that Cerrato signed in 2009 (plus any number of shortsighted restructures), and only one under Shanahan (Garcon). Although: the deadcap accumulation next year from the 2012 shopping spree is going to be significant.

But alright, compare that team to the current team.

QB - Campbell was a lot further along in his development under Zorn than RG3 is under Shanahan, which matters in performance evaluation, but Griffin is the better prospect (and four years younger than 2009 Campbell). I still think RG3 is a future all-pro in this league, and would take him over any other player in the 2012 QB class.

RB - Much better in 2013. Ladell Betts was a nice player at the end of his career. Portis had a lot left, and was just turning 30 (or so it seemed). But Morris is as good a pure runner as anyone in the league including Peterson and McCoy. Helu is a pretty damn good player to. And Darrel Young all day over a declining Mike Sellers.

WR - Wash. Santana Moss didn't appear to have a ton left in 2009, Randle El was a complementary player, and beyond the top two, the Redskins were abysmal. Anthony Armstrong though was on the roster, and although he didn't play on the 2009 Redskins, he might tip the scales slightly in favor of the 09 team? Maybe?

TE - More depth in 2009. Cooley was coming off back to back decline years, and Fred Davis looked promising. Wait, Todd Yoder was a Redskin? I'd take the 2013 roster (and I mean, Fred Davis in his pime is there if you need him -- but nah, we're good) because Jordan Reed is that good, but I'm not sure Reed would have even played TE just five years ago.

OL - 2013, but this is pretty close. Chris Samuels was basically retired. Stephon Heyer stayed healthy the full season, which was nice. But Casey Rabach, Derrick Dockery, and Mike Williams? For real? Interior line still needs improvement, but these guys were a disaster. The 2009 had some guys on the roster who went on to play for other organizations (Edwin Williams, Chad Rinehart...you can count Will Montgomery too). As an aside: Polumbus' 2013 reminds me a lot of Heyer's 2009.

DL - 2009. Andre Carter is one of the best players in the NFL at his position. Corneilius Griffin has recent productivity in his past, but he's about done. Kedric Golston is an effective player, still. Albert Haynesworth is an effective player, still. Brian Orakpo played some DL in passing downs only. Phillip Daniels somehow still going strong. Good depth. Now? Adam Carriker and Jarvis Jenkins remain major question marks. Stephen Bowen gives you a body who will answer the call every Sunday and little else, and Cofield is playing well despite being something of a liability against the run. Absolutely no depth.

LB - 2009, though this is closer than DL. Orakpo and Kerrigan are two of the best players on the current defense. Better than 2009 Orakpo and Rocky McIntosh. But 2009 London Fletcher was as good as anyone in the league. HB Blades was nice depth. 2013 London Fletcher, Perry Riley, and Nick Barnett are just totally overmatched. Also: Josh Hull is a Redskin?

DB - 2009, not close. Rogers in his prime, Landry heading into his, Hall (theoretically) with his best years ahead, Justin Tryon heading into year three, Kevin Barnes into year two (Kevin Barnes had a pretty nice year for us in 2011...and is out of the league two years later). Hall and Wilson are currently in their primes, Amerson is an inconsistent rookie, and there is nothing about the safety situation that lighting it on fire could not fix.

ST - Any year in history > 2013

I'd favor the 2009 team anywhere on defense and special teams, and at one or two spots on offense (out of 11). Similarities: a lot of players contributing now who are just about done (Chris Chester, Santana Moss, Fletcher, obviously).

You'd take the 2013 roster because Griffin. So this analysis was a lot longer than it needed to be (duh). Fundamentally, however, the problems are the same: old roster lacks talent at key positions.

Funny thing about this assessment is you most likely made this same type of opinionated responses in 2009 comparing the 2005 team. Lol

Which is sad..

Just woke up and realized culpepper and Cunningham played for the Vikings. Culpepper is the burly one lol. He was like 300 by end of his career.

Funny thing about this assessment is you most likely made this same type of opinionated responses in 2009 comparing the 2005 team. Lol

Which is sad..

2005 was an awesome defense, no comparison there son.

2009 defense and special teams were still far better than today's defense and special teams though, and today's offense isn't enough to compensate. Pretty simple but Tripps in depth analysis was awesome. But there again, an honest person has to acknowledge the offense today has a huge asterisk next to it. So many points and yards in garbage time, totally inconsistent and can't score to win games, based on a gimmicky scheme of diminishing marginal productivity and will absolutely shorten our franchise QBs career. As someone else said recently, even the earliest Shanahan critics didn't predict how inept his regime would be.

I say the above as an early critic. But that was based on my expectation of mediocrity, like 7-9 or 8-8 most seasons. Instead, and again even to my own surprise, it's been just fucking horrible 3 of 4 seasons with Mike.

Even recently I thought he deserved an OC job but the more you break things down I'm not sure he or Kyle have any business being in pro football.

Speaking for myself, and possible a lot of other fans, there were high expectations for this season, that the team is 3-6 again, and shows all of the signs of the problems from the past is a real head scratcher. Obviously there are problems, as a fan, and going through the miraculous run last year to finish 10-6, you get caught up in things, and I suppose everyone was all in on the team being a better team and winning the east again this year. Clearly, the Skins are not as good as any of us would have thought at the beginning of the season, and since they are playing a 1st place division winner schedule it shows that they cannot match up against the better teams in the NFL. The maddening aspect as just as in years past the lose to teams that they should not '13 Viking, '12 Rams ( I believe the Rams went through a 35 game stretch were they only won four games two against the Skins back when they had 1-15 season). This nonsense has been going on for twenty years, so I don't think there are any quick fixes at this stage, as much as I don't like Shanahan, I am not sure it would matter if you fired him and brought in someone else.

Back to the pocket passer BS for a moment

Robert Griffin III: 'I've got tough skin' - ESPN (http://espn.go.com/blog/nfceast/post/_/id/58714/rg-iii-ive-got-tough-skin)

Among the criticisms: He's not a pocket passer. For now, that's accurate as Griffin operates best when the Redskins ask him to be multi-dimensional. But he's been hot on third downs in the past two games, completing 16-of-21 passes for 196 yards and two touchdowns -- and most have come on straight dropbacks. He's third in the NFL the past two weeks on third downs with a total quarterback rating of 97.0, according to ESPN Stats & Information.

Matty you love your stats...lol.

Matty you love your stats...lol.

Stats are like a hot knife through a steaming pile of BS.

Blame Keim he wrote it. I'm just sharing the knowledge.

What a sad state of affairs when discussions become about "why" we are lousy. Lets beat the dumb birds tomorrow and take it from there.
HTTR