Taylor or Winslow

Come, where are my true Redskin Fans, Who think we've would have been better of with that Loud mouth Kellen Winslow Jr., I mean he come in camp late, at the Draft states that he will show the Redskins and the Lions for Passing on him, that they made a mistake, and then he breaks his leg....one way to keep him quiet, let me tell all you guys something, Sean Taylor, will be so good in the league, until he will be a perfect combination of Ronnie Lott, and Ed Reed, he will be a monster on the Field, so if you really wanted Winslow, then there's room at the Dog Pound for ya, holla back skin fans...:biggthump

KWII SUCKS. HE IS Total Bullshit Sean Is The Man. Forget About Kwii, Cooley Would Kick His Ass. Especially In Our Team First Mentality, Cooley Is A Team Player, Not A Me First Like Kwii.

Taylor For President!

We definitely got the better end of the deal on this one. Sean Taylor did a great job as a rookie and will only get better. Cooley also did a great job and has become one of our offensive go to guys. Look to see them both be even better this season. KWII is just the type of person we don't need in a Skins uniform. I'm sure the Browns are glad they have him!!!

Hes 40-0 in wrestling at high school

I was one fan who honestly would have been happy with either one. Taylor is going to be a huge impact player throughout his stay in DC, but just because Winslow 2 is a loud mouth immature punk right now, doesn't mean I wouldn't take him on the team if we had the oppurtunity. If he was a bit more mature, we wouldn't even be having this bashing of winslow because the guy has enormous god given talent especially for a TE. And u cannot compare cooley to winslow because they play 2 different positions(cooley=h-back/FB & winslow=TE/or even in the slot at WR) and I know I for one believe if we'd had both of those guys in our offense last year, things might have gone a bit differently. It definitely would have opened up some more possiblities of the WRs getting downfield. So enough with this winslow sucks crap until we actually see him play a full season to see if he was overhyped like his fellow cane shockey.

that right, skinfan, until we see him play a full season, so until that happens, then we don't know, all I know is that he had the outburst at the U, where he claimed to be a soilder, hired the posten brothers, to be his agent, where there known, to give teams problems, and stated that he will be greater than his dad......so I'll blast him all i want until he becomes the pro bowler he claims to be.........

Our defense was amazing and that was credit to our backfield and w/o taylor we were just not as good. In the Green Bay game it felt like we were giving up way to many big plays. We need him and he is big for the team. With that said we also needed more on the offensive end and KW would be an upgrade. We will never know how our team would be different but i like THIS offseason because it lost allittle on D and gained allittle on offense what we needed. That is in relation to the Taylor/ Wislow question, again not like we would ever know but would we be better overall if we had wislow someone who could be a force and be on the line. If we could trade would we most of us would say no because KW isn't proven in the NFL yet but it is to the question how much on D can we give up to still be good and how much would we gain on offense to be good ENOUGH

Guys - Let's not bash Winslow too bad. He had a bad break (no pun intended) as far as injuries go. He's a special player and he IS better than Chris Cooley. Especially at the Hback position. Now, would I rather have Taylor and Cooley over Winslow and Sean Jones (safety browns got in the 3rd), absolutely. I love Taylor and I'd rather have him than Winslow, but Winslow is a playmaker and a great TE in this league.

Why do you guys like some loudmouths but hate others? Portis, Smoot, LaVar, all loud mouthed and annoying, yet you love them. How about Mr. Holdout Patrick Ramsey. Don't see anyone ripping him about it. What about Ray Lewis who never shuts up, most of you get on your knees and praise him as if he's a demi-god instead of the aging overrated LB he is. In his prime he was great, but no longer!

KWII is going to be a great player in this league assuming his injury didn't cripple him!

KWII didn't get arrested for DUI, KWII didn't play agent roulette, KWII didn't get a deal then complain about it, and KWII missed the rookie synopsis.

I'd still rather have Taylor, but KWII certainly isn't a BAD player.

KW hasn't proven anything yet except he can take a big hit (remember when he got clocked in that preseason game!).

I think he's going to be a great pro, but he hasn't done jack just yet.

What happens when we sign Heath Miller? Sorry. I had to throw a wrench in the gears. :oink: