Chico23231
03-01-2013, 09:12 AM
No there definitely will not be three rookie quarterbacks starting in the playoffs in 2013. Last year's class was ridiculous. Three quarterbacks that went undrafted from last year's class are on rosters, not to mention that every drafted QB except Weeden exceeded expectations.
I do think there will be three QBs picked in the first round who will by and large be successful in the league though. Three is a lot different from seven or eight though.
Tripp you gettin a prospect rankings list together? post it when/if you do. thanks
My 3 top QBs: 1.Barkley 2. Tyler Wilson 3. Geno Smith
EARTHQUAKE2689
03-01-2013, 10:41 AM
Tripp you gettin a prospect rankings list together? post it when/if you do. thanks
My 3 top QBs: 1.Barkley 2. Tyler Wilson 3. Geno Smith
Mine consists of:
1. Geno Smith
2. Mike Glennon
3. Tyler Wilson
4. Ryan Nassib
5. Matt Barkley
artmonkforhallofamein07
03-01-2013, 11:07 AM
I am a WVU fan, and have been for years. There is no way that you can compare Geno to RG III. He is not in the same relm as III. Yeah you can look at his numbers but he was rather pathetic this year and without Trayvon his numbers would have been much worse.
His numbers are a touch inflated due to the fact that on multiple occasions he threw a pass behind or at the LOS to Tayvon, and he took it 50,60,70 yrds to the house.
Plus Geno is not the athlete nor does he have the ball handing skills of III.
SkinzWin
03-01-2013, 11:14 AM
Tripp you gettin a prospect rankings list together? post it when/if you do. thanks
My 3 top QBs: 1.Barkley 2. Tyler Wilson 3. Geno Smith
I don't think many people are putting Barkley at the top. He has arm strength issues. Definitely do not see him as a #1. But then again, this whole QB class is pretty weak.
Chico23231
03-01-2013, 11:20 AM
I don't think many people are putting Barkley at the top. He has arm strength issues. Definitely do not see him as a #1. But then again, this whole QB class is pretty weak.
Barkley and Wilson dealt with alot of crap this season. I think if you put both on better teams with less drama they woulda excelled. I think neither are top 15 or 20 picks or guys that step on the field ready to play year 1, well right off the bat. Maybe mid-season.
NYCskinfan82
03-01-2013, 03:44 PM
Redskins “Alternative" Mock Draft - Hogs Haven (http://www.hogshaven.com/2013/2/28/4041910/redskins-alternative-mock-draft)
What do you think of this draft.
Chico23231
03-01-2013, 03:54 PM
Redskins “Alternative" Mock Draft - Hogs Haven (http://www.hogshaven.com/2013/2/28/4041910/redskins-alternative-mock-draft)
What do you think of this draft.
really cant complain. the WR outta Tennesse is a beast. Question is Honey Badger a CB in the NFL? 4th round is good value to give him a shot with the Skins.
Alvin Walton
03-01-2013, 03:55 PM
I like the Rambo and Stoneburber picks.
A WR with our first pick?
CultBrennan59
03-01-2013, 04:14 PM
Justin Hunter has the hands of Greg Little..can't catch; way too many drops.
GTripp0012
03-01-2013, 04:49 PM
Tripp you gettin a prospect rankings list together? post it when/if you do. thanks
My 3 top QBs: 1.Barkley 2. Tyler Wilson 3. Geno SmithYeah. I've watched most of the prospects I'm going to watch, I've just been lazy about it.
I don't really see this as a weak QB class, at all. Geno Smith will go top ten this year, and would go top ten pretty much any year he came out. He's clearly a better prospect than Locker/Gabbert/Ponder/Mallet (I would have rated him above Newton as well, but I ended up being off on Newton). Barkley is probably going in the top ten as well. And if he goes seven/eight/nine, some team (likely one picking at the top) is going to maneuver and try to get Nassib in the 13-19 neighborhood of the first round.
So those three will go right away. My favorite of the "best of the rest" is Tyler Bray, but I think a draft day fall might actually work in his benefit. Bray was the first QB I studied, and my reaction right after was Bray was the best player -- player, not quarterback -- in the entire draft. I've backed off that position substantially, not because I've seen evidence to make me believe that's not the case, but because I was doing WAY too much justifying of a high grade on a player who is going to be a late riser, at best. Kind of like Kellen Moore last year. At this point, if you can get Bray late in the first round or early in the second, I would, but there's no reason to take him with a top ten pick: he doesn't have the intangibles the other three guys do (and he's really not mobile at all, in an era where mobility is so important to development of the QB), so the market for him won't be as fierce.
The rest of the class is mediocre. I like Sean Renfree (Duke), Zac Dysert (Miami) and Marquise Gray (Minnesota) as backup types with some trade value in the league down the road. I think EJ Manuel can be a system guy in the NFL, but he's not going to rise as sharply as some people think (late 2 or early 3 at best). I think Tyler Wilson and Sean Glennon are going to struggle, a lot. I still have no idea what on earth to think of Landry Jones. If Jones could demonstrate just one clear skill outside of his arm, he'd go high in this draft...I'm just not sure he has it. I think Collin Klein should probably play tight end, although you can make your case that backup quarterback-who-will-never-play is the single most coveted position in sports. I think Jordan Rodgers probably shouldn't be drafted.
I haven't yet seen Matt Scott play (I'm not sure I saw Arizona play at all last year), but I hear he's intriguing.