Colts Officially Release Peyton Manning (QB Thread #11)

Good chance Rex comes back, but it probably also depends on who else might hit the wire. Beck should be gone I think. Crompton... who cares.

Beck was ten times worse than Rex. At least Rex moved the ball, Beck looked like a scared rookie all over again. It doesn't matter if Rex is unsigned or not, Beck will not be coming back. We gave him over a year to learn the playbook while riding the bench, and he still failed miserably. Our backup will either be Rex, a free agent, or a rookie we take in the later rounds of the draft. But I bet it won't be Beck.

Beck basically was a rookie. That's why I said to keep him out there in a lost season.

Beck had mobility that Rex did not, and did not fumble whenever anyone breathed on him. He had a few advantages over Rex.

Doesn't matter which one is our backup, we're screwed if either of them have to play. Rex will move the ball and keep the games close, but will always choke when it matters most.

Good chance Rex comes back, but it probably also depends on who else might hit the wire. Beck should be gone I think. Crompton... who cares.

I care.

I care.

why?

Idk why rex would be back or beck honestly, the two don't even resemble.rgiii

Idk why rex would be back or beck honestly, the two don't even resemble.rgiii

Rex knows the offense well, good teammate. Cheap and available.

I tried, that's all I can come up with.

Rex knows the offense well, good teammate. Cheap and available.

I tried, that's all I can come up with.

Those are the only reasons we'd bring him back. I honestly think we're gonna go in an entirely different direction this offseason.

why?

I guess its because I'm always pulling for an underdog and Crompton is an underdog. But even with Grossman, while throwing for over 3,000 yards and moving the offense, the guy was still pitiful playing QB. Almost to the point that there have been mentions in the Washington Post about the Redskins taking the option of not re-signing him. Beck...I don't want to say anything else about Beck. He's a total bum. Although Crompton is young(24), would he really be that much worse than Beck or Grossman?

I guess its because I'm always pulling for an underdog and Crompton is an underdog. But even with Grossman, while throwing for over 3,000 yards and moving the offense, the guy was still pitiful playing QB. Almost to the point that there have been mentions in the Washington Post about the Redskins taking the option of not re-signing him. Beck...I don't want to say anything else about Beck. He's a total bum. Although Crompton is young(24), would he really be that much worse than Beck or Grossman?

I really don't know anything about the guy, so I could care less.

I know fans tend to have a soft spot for the unknown backup QB, but when does that guy ever pan out?

Trent Green was probably the last one here. And that was ages ago.

Those are the only reasons we'd bring him back. I honestly think we're gonna go in an entirely different direction this offseason.

Might be a bit risky to not have one QB in the stable experienced in Mike/Kyle's esoteric system. Also if Rex is as good a guy as reported he could help RGIII develop.