Big Game QB with 2 Minutes Left

Actually, I might take Manning!

Joe Montana lived for the 2 min drill!! Brady has been the best since Montana. But He needs to keep it up for a few more years.
John Elway was great. But He didn't win sh-t untill Terrell Davis showed up.And Farve is amazing but throws way to many pic's to be a great 2 min drill QB.
I would rate them
#1 Motana
#2 Brady
#3 Elway
#4 Farve
But really there all H.O.F'ers I would take all of them over any of are old QB's!!!

hello heath shuler

If I could take one QB in his prime to build a team around, it's gotta be Montana hands down. Best QB to have played the game IMO.

Montana. Always came through in the clutch and never threw an int in the playoffs.
never threw an INT in the Super Bowl...but did throw plenty of INTs during the playoffs

Montana Postseason Stats (23 games, 16-7 W-L Record):
463-732 (63%), 5772 yds, 44 TDs, 21 INTs (2 Rushing TDs)

Elway Postseason Stats (22 games, 14-8 W-L Record):
355-650 (55%), 4964 yds, 27 TDs, 21 INTs (6 Rushing TDs)

As others have said, if I had to build a team, I'd take Montana hands down. However, with the game on the line, no one did more times than Elway.
Calling Elway Mr. Comeback (http://profootballhof.com/enshrinement/release.jsp?release_id=1209)

matter of opinion of course...can claim plenty for both...

I went with Brady I believe when it's all said and done he will be considered the best of all time he is Montana like, with a better arm, the other's where probably more gifted physically but they didn't have the smart's that Montana, or Brady possess, Montana was a benefactor of the west coast offense and Bill Walsh, we have seen QB after QB become all pro's in that san fran system and do nothing else where, we have seen Bledsoe fail in New England, and Brady prosper. Brady is a special QB I would take him in any offensive situation on the field.

my list would montana, brady, leftwhich, elway, then others

I went with Brady I believe when it's all said and done he will be considered the best of all time he is Montana like, with a better arm, the other's where probably more gifted physically but they didn't have the smart's that Montana, or Brady possess, Montana was a benefactor of the west coast offense and Bill Walsh, we have seen QB after QB become all pro's in that san fran system and do nothing else where, we have seen Bledsoe fail in New England, and Brady prosper. Brady is a special QB I would take him in any offensive situation on the field.

In the golden years of Montana when he went to Kansas City, I thought he had some decent success....I mean no Super bowl's but I believe he did get the Chiefs to the AFC Championship didn't he? Being that He played under Marty....we can all assume that wasn't a West Coast offense.

I went with Brady I believe when it's all said and done he will be considered the best of all time he is Montana like, with a better arm, the other's where probably more gifted physically but they didn't have the smart's that Montana, or Brady possess, Montana was a benefactor of the west coast offense and Bill Walsh, we have seen QB after QB become all pro's in that san fran system and do nothing else where, we have seen Bledsoe fail in New England, and Brady prosper. Brady is a special QB I would take him in any offensive situation on the field.

So, do you think Charlie Weiss' impact will have a minimal impact on Tom Brady and the rest of the Pats' offense?

So, do you think Charlie Weiss' impact will have a minimal impact on Tom Brady and the rest of the Pats' offense?


I do feel it will be minimal, I feel the new england cooridinators are a product of Belichik they run what Belichik want's, especially on the defensive side of the ball if you saw late in the pittsburg game it was Belichik reeming some player's on the field on the defensive end about there positioning not Romeo, I believe the buck stop's with Belichik, but like any QB he need's the right coaches and player's around him to succeed, if Marino played for Gibb's his whole carreer we would be saying without a doubt [IMO] that he was the greatest of all time, so a lot of thing's factor into a QB's success but I feel Brady is and has been the best at capitalizing on his situation he's not a short passing game QB like Montana, he can throw the deep ball as accurate as anyone in the game, and does so regularly, as well as making every clutch throw that is presented to him, I look for him to destroy Philli next sunday.