The Big Rumor: If The Colts Take Luck, Then Manning Could Be...

I'm not trying to be an ass, but i'm just curious why you stalk this forum? Is your life so boring you need to post on sites of teams you don't even follow? I personally just have better things to do than get on the eagles, cowboys, or giants forum and post my opinion.

Why does it matter? Out of all the NFCE rival fans on this forum, Giantone is probably the only one who mans up when the Redskins beat his team. That alone deserves respect. And it's not like the only thing he does is spew hatred and vitriol towards us.

So how do you know ginatone? Are you friends with him and his dad? I think a case could be made for Peyton playing in the same division as his brother.


I guess a case could be made but I just go back to when Eli was drafted and the switch was made with the Chargers ...one reason was becuase the Mannings (Archie and the Mrs) ...wanted the boys to be as seperated as possible.The boys always do what mom says.

That was ten year or so ago. We are also discussing a 36 year old man. I know we all listen to our mother, but who knows if this is still the case. We are also talking about a time when they were most lkely trying to protect the younger Manning from constantly being compared to his brother. Well as we have seen little Eli doesn't need anyone to protect his legacy anymore. The kid has got it, and seeing those two battle it out twice a year for a couple of years would not be all bad for either one or the fam.

I just don't think it was something that you could write off as easily as you seem to do.

BTW sorry for the mispell. and CONGRATS ON BEATING THE PACKERS NICE WIN YESTERDAY!!

Eli's trade back in the day had absolutely nothing to do with playing in the same conferences. It had everything to do with AJ Smith and the front office of San Diego.

BTW sorry for the mispell. and CONGRATS ON BEATING THE PACKERS NICE WIN YESTERDAY!!


Thank you, at my age I'm just happy to find the key board,it's a fan forum I'm not here to judge anyone on spelling or grammer.

Eli's trade back in the day had absolutely nothing to do with playing in the same conferences. It had everything to do with AJ Smith and the front office of San Diego.

There were a bunch of reason's all I said was the family did'nt want them in the same divison was one of them.

im not buying that...^... but for logical reasons i say we its a 50-50 shot

Thank you, at my age I'm just happy to find the key board,it's a fan forum I'm not here to judge anyone on spelling or grammer.

yeah but ginatone sounds like a shot to me! :)

Manning is more of the same. I don't see how acquiring him will pay off in the long run. Sure it could work but this is a guy that may never take another snap ever again.

nfldraftupdate Dion Caputi
Archie Manning, Peyton's father: "Peyton kind of likes his roots in Indy." Also said his son's main priority is to get healthy & play again.
11 minutes ago

BMack764 Bill Porter
Peyton Manning Wants To Return To Indianapolis Colts, Neck Still Not Healthy footballnewsnow.com/2012/peyton-ma… via @AddThis
2 hours ago Favorite Retweet Reply

A pretty good source just dropped on me that Peyton has been medically advised to never play again. If true, I'm sure it'll leak out soon enough.

If so, the Skins should totally stay away from this guy.