|
SBXVII 12-29-2011, 07:53 PM I don't blame JC for not "competing." He was, and is, better than each QB Mike and Kyle brought in. And...he was already in DC and didn't cost picks etc.
The humor on this board is sometimes overwhelming. JC is just as bad, or equal to Grossman. There I said it. JC made bad decisions, JC was not accurate on the long ball, JC needed all day to throw, JC might have been able to scramble better then Grossman I'll give you that, but otherwise his down side was similar to Grossmans and it would have taken him more then one offseason to learn the scheme... ie; McNabb. Grossman knew more then JC in regards to the scheme he just needed the WR's and OL to catch up to him. Now that they are close in understanding the scheme getting a better QB is in order.
SirClintonPortis 12-29-2011, 08:15 PM JC-to-McNabb was a lateral move. A foolish, costly lateral move, but still a lateral move. Had we kept JC, patience with him would be wearing very thin by now and he might have lost out to Grossman anyway, just like McNabb.
SBXVII 12-29-2011, 08:24 PM Why would it matter? It's not like you can go watch them practice, except the few that are open in training camp.
Actually your right. But VA can't get a NFL team cause Snyder wants to claim it will take away from his revenue. So no pro team for VA. They have had their home office in VA for years. DC wants the team playing in DC again, I'd be ok with that. I guess even if they decided to make the stadium their home office but I'm getting tired of Maryland wanting to take everything. They have the Ravens. Let the Redskins stay in DC or VA.
redskin29633 12-29-2011, 08:26 PM The humor on this board is sometimes overwhelming. JC is just as bad, or equal to Grossman. There I said it. JC made bad decisions, JC was not accurate on the long ball, JC needed all day to throw, JC might have been able to scramble better then Grossman I'll give you that, but otherwise his down side was similar to Grossmans and it would have taken him more then one offseason to learn the scheme... ie; McNabb. Grossman knew more then JC in regards to the scheme he just needed the WR's and OL to catch up to him. Now that they are close in understanding the scheme getting a better QB is in order.
Really makes me wonder why Gibbs was so fascinated with Campbell. When he was at Auburn, I could never see anything that would lead you to conclude that he would become even an average NFL QB. That's one that I will probably never understand.
Given the choice I'd gladly take JC over Grossman. JC might not be a game breaker (neither is Grossman), but he's not going to kill you with INTs either. He's an efficient game manager that can win games in this league with a supporting cast. Sooner or later Grossman will kill you with a crucial INT or fumble.
SirClintonPortis 12-29-2011, 09:23 PM Really makes me wonder why Gibbs was so fascinated with Campbell. When he was at Auburn, I could never see anything that would lead you to conclude that he would become even an average NFL QB. That's one that I will probably never understand.
Gibbs thought very highly of Rypien and Williams. He saw qualities in them that he saw in Campbell.
Hail to the Redskins 12-29-2011, 09:41 PM One guy that hasn't been mentioned is WR Malcolm Floyd out of Notre Dame... I know a lot of people on here are in love with Justin Blackmon... but Floyd is a monster. Great size, strong as an Ox, can leap, and has great hands.
I've liked him since last year.
When is he supposed to go? Late 1st?
I seriously doubt we end up with him... but I think he's going to be a good pro.
skinsfaninok 12-29-2011, 10:02 PM One guy that hasn't been mentioned is WR Malcolm Floyd out of Notre Dame... I know a lot of people on here are in love with Justin Blackmon... but Floyd is a monster. Great size, strong as an Ox, can leap, and has great hands.
I've liked him since last year.
When is he supposed to go? Late 1st?
I seriously doubt we end up with him... but I think he's going to be a good pro.
Many said the same about Golden Tate, in fact who was the Last ND WR to even be good in the NFL? Tim Brown?
Chico23231 12-29-2011, 10:29 PM Many said the same about Golden Tate, in fact who was the Last ND WR to even be good in the NFL? Tim Brown?
Floyd is a much better prospect than Tainte. Floyd got enough talent to go top 10. Anything after the first round for Floyd would be an epic steal.
Lotus 12-29-2011, 10:32 PM One guy that hasn't been mentioned is WR Malcolm Floyd out of Notre Dame... I know a lot of people on here are in love with Justin Blackmon... but Floyd is a monster. Great size, strong as an Ox, can leap, and has great hands.
I've liked him since last year.
When is he supposed to go? Late 1st?
I seriously doubt we end up with him... but I think he's going to be a good pro.
I've thought about him and Kendall Wright.
Wouldn't it be sweet to take a QB at sevenish and then trade back into the late first round to get Floyd or Wright?
|