|
|
Chico23231 10-16-2011, 06:56 PM Unless Ryan Kerrigan turns into a year-in year-out All Pro, (and I think he could), not taking a QB in the last draft might be legitimately questioned.
Especially if there's still not going to be a QB worth taking next year. How long can you go without even starting to look for your quarterback of the future?
No way, Kerrigan was the right choice. The QB last draft class wasnt very good. We made the right moves in the draft.
This year's top prospects are much higher quality guys IMO. Much better.
SirClintonPortis 10-16-2011, 06:59 PM Unless Ryan Kerrigan turns into a year-in year-out All Pro, (and I think he could), not taking a QB in the last draft might be legitimately questioned.
Especially if there's still not going to be a QB worth taking next year. How long can you go without even starting to look for your quarterback of the future?
You have to debate Ponder/Gabbert at 10 vs. what we got instead, which includes Kerrigan, Hankerson, Gomes, and Hurt.
Slingin Sammy 33 10-16-2011, 07:04 PM No way, Kerrigan was the right choice. The QB last draft class wasnt very good. We made the right moves in the draft.
This year's top prospects are much higher quality guys IMO. Much better.agree 100%
SirClintonPortis 10-16-2011, 07:07 PM One thing about Shanahan is that he will not take a QB unless he's truly a skilled one. That's why Cutler is the only 1st round QB he has ever taken.
Lotus 10-16-2011, 07:08 PM You have to debate Ponder/Gabbert at 10 vs. what we got instead, which includes Kerrigan, Hankerson, Gomes, and Hurt.
This is true.
And Ponder presumably has not shown enough to unseat DMac5. Gabbert has played poorly. So if we were looking for a QB for RIGHT NOW, neither of those guys would have provided much of an option.
irish 10-16-2011, 07:44 PM This
Its funny cause I never thought JC was much of a game manager, he always seemed lost out there. It also amazed me that for a guy that played QB his whole life he had 0 pocket awareness.
I think the Skins are better coached and schemed than they have been in years but my bigests concern with Shanny is that he has never done anything with with with a QB not named Elway.
Hail to the Redskins 10-16-2011, 07:53 PM No way, Kerrigan was the right choice. The QB last draft class wasnt very good. We made the right moves in the draft.
This year's top prospects are much higher quality guys IMO. Much better.
Not to start an argument, but this QB class wasn't good, huh??
Newton is lighting it up and Dalton has been very effective... leading the Bengals to a 4-2 record. Ponder looked decent in preseason as well... can't judge this class yet, really, but they aren't terrible I know that and I know there is at least 2 that are better than what we have now.
Kerrigan was the right choice... but right now, I think I'd take Dalton over Hankerson, Gomes, and Hurd combined.... that's just me.
Chico23231 10-16-2011, 08:04 PM Not to start an argument, but this QB class wasn't good, huh??
Newton is lighting it up and Dalton has been very effective... leading the Bengals to a 4-2 record. Ponder looked decent in preseason as well... can't judge this class yet, really, but they aren't terrible I know that and I know there is at least 2 that are better than what we have now.
Kerrigan was the right choice... but right now, I think I'd take Dalton over Hankerson, Gomes, and Hurd combined.... that's just me.
Cam been super human. Locker, yet to be seen. But neither were in a position to be drafted by us. Ponder and Gabbert were reaches. Dalton, yeah id take him, but not over Kerrigan. I liked Dalton coming out...not as a first round pick. Take a look at some of the QBs coming out this year, there is some really good talent.
53Fan 10-16-2011, 08:11 PM No way, Kerrigan was the right choice. The QB last draft class wasnt very good. We made the right moves in the draft.
This year's top prospects are much higher quality guys IMO. Much better.
Absolutely agree. Hard to argue with one of, if not the best, drafts we've had in years. And as you mention, by all accounts this years QB class should be much better. I think the FO did an excellent job and had the foresight to look ahead to next years class.
Absolutely agree. Hard to argue with one of, if not the best, drafts we've had in years. And as you mention, by all accounts this years QB class should be much better. I think the FO did an excellent job and had the foresight to look ahead to next years class.
Matt Barkley in a Skins Uniform? Maybe....thing is This unknown we have on the roster would really need to screw up next week
|