For those of you who don't want to let go...

Should we break the bank to try to re-sign Smoot or possibly go after Phillip Buchanon?

http://www.nfl.com/teams/story/OAK/8047465

Next question is, what and/or who do we give up for him?

Phillip Buchanon has problems. I'd rather keep Smoot.

Smoot over him any day. If were not gonna get smoot, we shouldnt throw a ton of money at a big name FA such as Buchanon. We should get another role player in there, who can do the job. We dont need some flashy dude in there. I personally want Smoot back really bad though.

I agree, I'd much rather keep Smoot. I wouldn't want the other guy anyway. We don't need Showtime, we need a team player (SMOOT).

Don't bring this guy here...he had a monster yr in 2003 - 6 INTs and 2 punt return TDs , but he's not a character guy - he's actually aping the old pimp Deion. He'd be a bad signing for us.

Exactly what I thought when I read that article, another Deion wanna be. We didn't need Deion and we don't need this guy!!!