Skinsfaninok's Available NFL QBs Poll

If not Young I wouldn't take any of these guys honestly, maybe Smith as a Wildcard but thats a push

If Young had a solid head on his shoulders he would be dangerous.

So would a lot of players.

Vince Young has never been good?
Hyperbole much?

Never in the pros and who cares about college.

Donovan McNabb

Vince Young is a sexy idea IMO, the guy has some extremely rare talents as an athlete, had good pocket presence and can make something out of nothing BUT he's not a good passer, so for a season or 2 while a rookie learns the league, I'm ok w having young to step in.. Hey he cant be any worse than rex

Young has never been good.
Never in the pros and who cares about college.Rah rah Vince Young has never been good rah rah arrgh!

To believe that Vince Young has never been good you're forced to disregard Win/Loss: 26-13

You would also have to disregard his 2010/9 stats:

2010-59.6 comp%-10 TDs-3 INTs-8.0 YPA-98.6 QBR
24% of rushes result in 1st downs/25 atts

2009-58.7 comp%-10 TDs-7 INTs-7.3 YPA-82.8 QBR

You would have to disregard him being a 2-Time Pro-Bowler.

There is too much you have to disregard from a football stand point that preclude the statement Vince Young has never been good from being true to the point that it makes you lose credibility.

Now, if you want to say Vince Young appears to be a bad fit for Kyle's offense, I would agree.

If you want to say that Vince Young is thin skinned, I would agree.

On the flip side you would also have to question wether the FO other then owner were ever really 100% behind Vince and what type of impact that has on a QB or team leader.

The HC-OC/QB coach relationship is like a boxer/trainer.
If the trainer doesn't have faith in the boxer you greatly limit that's boxer's potential.

Sorry but 30GUT is right on about young.. Bottom line is the guy is a winner and was in college also, stats are nice but it's all about winning

until Young gets his head on straight,I say NO!.If the skins draft a QB #1 I thought the plan was bring back grossman until the rookie was ready?Palmer is not leaving cincy,hasselback won't leave seattle,kolb is over priced.

bulger and smith may be a fit if the price is right.

All of them are suspect, but Kolb at this point of time is the best choice. If this poll was given 5 years ago, I would have said Bulger. Young would have had to have one more season back as a starter to convince me he has matured into a bona fide starter.