Redskins Reconstruction: Quarterbacks

Hey guys, original question, who would you rather have Vince Young or Jason Campbell?

Campbell. Oh wait, I want a team to be able to do better than 8-8. If VY can get his head straight in a new venue, definitely him. I've been paralleling Alex Smith and Jason Campbell recently. I don't think Campbell has the IT to take a team all the way.

Young over JC but not that much

That's like picking spinach over brussel sprouts!

I love spinach!

Someone asked me if I were a betting man, would I say VY will be the Redskins starter on opening day. Um...my guess is no. Nor will it be Palmer, or Hasselbeck, or Smith, or any other non-Redskin NFL QB rumored or not rumored. I think Grossman will be the opening day starter and a month into the season (give or take a week) the QB I expect us to take in the mid 1st to mid 2nd (probably Dalton, Locker, or Ponder) will be starting.

Then again, around this time last year I bet that we'd sign Grossman but that he'd be cut by the end of preseason, so....shows what I know

Young would be a waste of a pickup. I still say draft a QB this season and next or just draft one and get a young FA this year. No more perennial backups like Garcia, they just don't win. I rather have a young gun get some teething time in even if he gets a bit roughed up.

Hey guys, original question, who would you rather have Vince Young or Jason Campbell?

If you are asking which one as the "bridge QB until we get a young QB up to speed" then Campbell (or just freaking Grossman), b/c that would have meant not wasting draft picks on McNabb.

Young would be a waste of a pickup. I still say draft a QB this season and next or just draft one and get a young FA this year. No more perennial backups like Garcia, they just don't win. I rather have a young gun get some teething time in even if he gets a bit roughed up.


I just don't see MS going in with a Rookie or just Rex next season, I thought Orton would be the guy until the last week or so I thought VY could be the guy, honestly if we have to trade for him I'd give them AH for VY

Isn't VY a free agent? I thought I heard somewhere saying that the Titants were planning on releasing him.

Isn't VY a free agent? I thought I heard somewhere saying that the Titants were planning on releasing him.


I'm not so sure I thought he is still under contract (cba shit not included)