IF We Take A QB At #10...Who Do You Want?

Should have clarified and said you've got to pick a QB at 10

Of certain things, the Redskins can be clear—even if they can't get a front line, immediate starter, the Redskins still need to draft a quarterback. While Rex Grossman can be a short-term solution, the 'Skins have to think long term.

Cam Newton is too much of an unknown to run a NFL offensive formation. That is too much of a gamble at #10 and I would stay away from him. He might love the game but drop back passers are the way to go.

Cam will have to learn how to read defensives. He has to be quick enough to check down. He just does not have that going for him. Lastly, he must be QB smart. I see talent in him to escape the pressure, but that's not playing the position.

I like the sleeper in Andy Dalton. Please, no more Auburn QBs.

Cam Newton is too much of an unknown to run a NFL offensive formation. That is too much of a gamble at #10 and I would stay away from him. He might love the game but drop back passers are the way to go.

Cam will have to learn how to read defensives. He has to be quick enough to check down. He just does not have that going for him. Lastly, he must be QB smart. I see talent in him to escape the pressure, but that's not playing the position.

I like the sleeper in Andy Dalton. Please, no more Auburn QBs.

You aren't alone in not wanting Newton in DC. Check it out.

Redskins Blog (http://blog.redskins.com/2011/01/20/the-internet-responds-to-the-existence-of-cam-newton-and-the-red/)

Cam Newton is too much of an unknown to run a NFL offensive formation. That is too much of a gamble at #10 and I would stay away from him. He might love the game but drop back passers are the way to go.

Cam will have to learn how to read defensives. He has to be quick enough to check down. He just does not have that going for him. Lastly, he must be QB smart. I see talent in him to escape the pressure, but that's not playing the position.

I like the sleeper in Andy Dalton. Please, no more Auburn QBs.

I've been high on Dalton for a while, guy is a winner and very underrated arm

Newton seems like another VY to me

Newton seems like another VY to me

I agree with that but I think VY is almost worse. Cam just seems flashy to me. VY is almost skitzo with multiple personalities or bipolar or something.

I think he's definitely a burrito short of a taco stand, if you catch my drift.

I agree with that but I think VY is almost worse. Cam just seems flashy to me. VY is almost skitzo with multiple personalities or bipolar or something.

I think he's definitely a burrito short of a taco stand, if you catch my drift.

Yeah VY has dealt with mental health issues.

There's just no way to know what kind o factor that played in evaluating his career. My bet is that it was a major factor in stunting his development.

Fool me once, shame on you. Fool me twice, shame on me.

I hear you,but the potential upside for Kolb is a lot different then Mcnabb,so much so i dont think the Eagles would do it.As far as Vince goes,i know he's a head case,but whos to say he cant mature like Vick.But knowing vince,he probably thinks he needs to be the starter somewhere and want a lot of money and wont settle for a backup role

It's pretty doubtful that Newton is a good fit for Kyle's system. Many of us (and analysts) are hung up on what Mike's QBs have looked for but Kyle is calling the plays. Based on some of the McNabb issues, it doesn't seem like Kyle is much for an improvisational QB or one whose strengths are creating their own plays outside the structure of the offense.

I love Newton's long term upside and even though I voted for him in this poll, the more I think of it he's not the best fit for us.

Newton seems like another VY to me

Let me make this clear: I don't want Cam Newton to be the starting quarterback for the Redskins. Not now. Not next year. Not in seven years, provided McNabb's incentive-laden contract expires. Newton is Vince Young in training: a big, rangy kid with a national championship - and more baggage than will fit in the overhead compartment. Let him be somebody else's project.

2011 NFL Draft: Quarterback Will Be the Focus For Washington Redskins, But Should It Be? - SB Nation DC (http://dc.sbnation.com/washington-redskins/2011/1/10/1925945/2011-nfl-draft-redskins-quarterback-mike-shanahan)