Is it finally time to rebuild??

These threads do seem very similar, don't they? I'd merge them but I'm refusing to participate in mod activities except for in nickel packages

Lol, I'd say they're pretty similar. I put up my preliminary plan for a rebuild before in the other thread and didn't want to copy and paste it here. I figured, "if you want my plans for a rebuild, see this post."

Although, the more I read through them, they seem like they seem like the same thread

Was thinking about starting a thread related to this. I think we trade Moss and Cooley if there are any takers.

Two of my favorite Skins, but when it is all said and done I will love the Skins well after they are old and gray. Have to think about the team and I just want to blow it up and start over again. Picks help.

Graham Gano essentially represents the conundrum Redskins fans face. Ask every 5 Redskins fans, and probably 3 want him gone. But if you want to rebuild, you probably have to have patience and put up with Gano missing some kicks, Sundberg botching a snap, Banks fumbling, Riley committing a penalty, Moore missing a tackle...that said, there's a fine (very fine) line between being patient and holding on for too long

I agree SS...In the case of Gano, there wasn't a lot of pressure on him to make either of the kicks he missed yesterday We play so many close games that in most instances a F/G often decides the outcome of the game. Should the team ever get to the point where it can score touchdowns and not be so dependent on F/G's some of the pressure may be relieved on the young kicker. Another case where a little patience should be exhibited.

Waiting for Tanner's wrath....

Sure, we've been saying this for years, and Shanahan decided not to rebuild last year. I still wonder whether that was the right choice. BUT - now our starting #1 WR is 32 with few options behind him, our best LB and key to the defense is Fletcher (36) and here's an abbreviated list of one of the oldest rosters on the planet (ages for 2011):

P.Daniels - will be 38
McNabb - will be 35
Fletcher - will be 36
Casay Rabach - will be 34
Artis Hicks - will be 32
Santana Moss - will be 32
Andre Carter - will be 32
Kemo - will be 32
D. Dockery - will be 31
Clinton Portis - will be 30
Roydell Williams - will be 30

Cooley - will be 29
J.Brown - will be 29

I won't mention Galloway is all but already retired.

The question is - can we fix this team in 2-3 years? If not, we should rebuild, dump older players and accept a couple of bad seasons as they get experience. The Capitals rebuilt and now has one of the best young rosters in the league for years to come. The Eagles and Tampa Bay also come to mind with young talent.

The second question is: since coaches are rewarded for success - is there no incentive for Shanahan to rebuild because he knows that he could get fired if he does not deliver success within 2 years?

Look at those players on your list and look how many might be gone this offseason.

P.Daniels - I think he might retire after this one, it sounds like 15 NFL seasons has started to take his toll on his body, and judging from him not showing up on the injury report with anything serious means it's just a lot of aches and pains that won't go away.

McNabb - staying obviously
Fletcher - probably staying
Casey Rabach - Definitely needs to go
Hicks - Stay or go, if he stays he needs to go to being a backup
Santana Moss - Stay, we already have enough holes to fill, we don't need to fill his #1 wideout spot right now
Carter - If we are going to fully commit to a 3-4 next season he needs to go. See if we can get something for him trade wise and if not (probably not) just cut him.
Kemo - He can stay, just needs to be a backup
Dockery - He can go, he's just wasting a roster spot
Portis - He can stay if he is healthy, but if he does stay next year will likely be his last as a Redskin.
Roydell Williams - I think we can do better than him but if he's gone it's no biggie.
Cooley - Might be trade bait, one of the few players of value the Skins have and I wouldn't mind Davis being our full time te if he's more consistent.
Jammal Brown - stay.

So when you look at that list there's probably 3-4 starters in there and the rest will either be cut or be backup players. I wouldn't mind rebuilding here but as has been mentioned it's something the fans wouldn't like (it means committing to most likely having a losing season that would be better for us in the long run) and I'm not sure Danny would like it either. I think he doesn't mind the idea of rebuilding but he's probably also concerned with how to keep profits up during a/multiple losing seasons. It's not like the way we're doing things now is working though, depending on your definition.

We have NOT tried to rebuild yet. A lot of people equate losing to rebuilding. Just because we suck doesn’t mean we’re rebuilding. We’re still giving up draft picks for 34 year old players. That is not rebuilding – that’s saying we want to win now. If you want to pick up some veteran FA’s. Fine. If you are trading for them, sacrificing young future players for the team, you’re still trying to win.
I’m ready to break the core of this team apart. See what we can get some value for, turn to the younger players. Start building a new attitude in DC. Not saying trade away everyone. But keep age in mind. Anyone over the age of 27/28 should be expendable, for the right price.Amen Bro! It is time to stockpile and place value on draft picks, and rebuild primarily through the draft. Regardless of who has led our FO, one constant under Snyder's ownership is the trading of draft picks for veterans, as if we're one or two players away from contending. The two playoff appearances in Gibbs 2.0 were a mirage. Those teams had losing records before making final sprints to eek out a #6 seed. They created delusion in the FO that we were close. I would even argue that cutting an able young body like Devin Thomas in favor of older players like Galloway and Roydell Williams may satisfy Shanny's desire to win now, but is counter-productive to getting younger, faster, and stronger in the long term. As a fan, I will willingly take a couple more crappy 5-6 win seasons if it means that the roster is being turned over for a future loaded with young talent ready to contend in 3 years. Time to take a longer term approach if we ever hope to compete in our division, much less make the playoffs.

Was thinking about starting a thread related to this. I think we trade Moss and Cooley if there are any takers.

Two of my favorite Skins, but when it is all said and done I will love the Skins well after they are old and gray. Have to think about the team and I just want to blow it up and start over again. Picks help.

Why do we gotta trade Cooley? Why not just trade Davis? Cooley is a pro bowler and Davis has become obsolete recently. We hardly hear of him. He's young and did step in well for Cooley when Cooley was injured so why not just throw him out as trade bait?

You get rid of Cooley for picks or something then you have to replace Cooley. You trade Davis (hopefully for a pick) you still have talent at TE. Plus every team has a player with a cool name they draw out when a great play is made. Ours is COOOOOOOLLLEEEEEEEYYYYYY! Sorry just can't get rid of him. We won't get much for Moss, he's old, and usually has a hammy or groin pull. Same with Portis.

We have a better chance of simply trading out of our mid round 1st pick for a late round 1st and late round 2nd or 3rd vs. trading people away for picks. Trust me if they are valuable to others then they should be valuable to us. Especially since we have so few valuable pieces.

Trading draft picks for older players (over 30) has happened much much much less frequently than we fans seem to want to think it has. Aside from McNabb, how many times have we done that in recent years? I'm sure there have been a couple other times, but I really can't think of them

Amen Bro! It is time to stockpile and place value on draft picks, and rebuild primarily through the draft. Regardless of who has led our FO, one constant under Snyder's ownership is the trading of draft picks for veterans, as if we're one or two players away from contending. The two playoff appearances in Gibbs 2.0 were a mirage. Those teams had losing records before making final sprints to eek out a #6 seed. They created delusion in the FO that we were close. I would even argue that cutting an able young body like Devin Thomas in favor of older players like Galloway and Roydell Williams may satisfy Shanny's desire to win now, but is counter-productive to getting younger, faster, and stronger in the long term. As a fan, I will willingly take a couple more crappy 5-6 win seasons if it means that the roster is being turned over for a future loaded with young talent ready to contend in 3 years. Time to take a longer term approach if we ever hope to compete in our division, much less make the playoffs.

This pretty much sums up my thought process as well. Right now, this team is horrid. They need to make bold moves and, I believe, get rid of a lot of the "good" players they have as opposed to relying on them even more.

I think that as long as guys like Rogers, Hall, Moss, and Portis are on the roster, this team is going to sit back and think they are set at those positions. That shouldn't be the case. I would seriously have a roster next season that didn't include one of them! Having Santana as a #1 is really hurting the offense. Torain was released after camp because Portis was on the team. This can't continue to happen. The aging vets HAVE to go. That's the only way this team will improve. Have a fire sale and see what you can get. If the answer is "not much," so be it.

This team will never win the way it's currently constructed. They're so far from Super Bowl contention right now that they have no choice but to blow this thing up.

I agree SS...In the case of Gano, there wasn't a lot of pressure on him to make either of the kicks he missed yesterday We play so many close games that in most instances a F/G often decides the outcome of the game. Should the team ever get to the point where it can score touchdowns and not be so dependent on F/G's some of the pressure may be relieved on the young kicker. Another case where a little patience should be exhibited.

I think people are forgetting that it most likely was not about pressure but instead about how soft the field was. I'm betting Gano could not plant his left foot like he usually likes to do in order to get a good swing of his right leg into hitting the ball. I'd almost bet a lot on the fact Gano had to adjust his kicking due to the fact he didn't want to slip and fall while trying to kick which the adjustment alone probably caused his troubles. No different then McNabb having to adjust his throws or game plan if it's a windy day.