firstdown
11-08-2010, 10:41 AM
There's a log jam at QB in Philly as they have 2 legit starters. I wouldnt be surprised if Philly decides 1 will be the starter and moves the other.
To answer the question do I want MV here? No, he's a nice regular season QB but his run & throw style just doesnt win Super Bowls.
If you said that about him while he was with the Falcons I would have agreed but MV is turning into a pocket passer that can also run. He is the number one rated QB in the NFL right now.
44ever
11-08-2010, 10:53 AM
If you said that about him while he was with the Falcons I would have agreed but MV is turning into a pocket passer that can also run. He is the number one rated QB in the NFL right now.
Your a fool to argue with this^^^^ Like it or not Vick is a Great QB! My guess is he plays out the rest of his productive career as a Eagle.
Chico23231
11-08-2010, 10:56 AM
Mike Vick is going to get an effing HUGE contract at the end of the year. Guy is playing lights out AGAIN. But I would pass on Vick...to much of an injury risk
SolidSnake84
11-08-2010, 11:27 AM
Mike Vick is going to get an effing HUGE contract at the end of the year. Guy is playing lights out AGAIN. But I would pass on Vick...to much of an injury risk
What has happened to Vick over his career to make you say that?? he got hit in the ribs this year...but I can't recall other than that where he missed serious time....definatley not like McNabb, who has missed at least 4 games a year in every season except 1 that I can think of...
SmootSmack
11-08-2010, 11:38 AM
What has happened to Vick over his career to make you say that?? he got hit in the ribs this year...but I can't recall other than that where he missed serious time....definatley not like McNabb, who has missed at least 4 games a year in every season except 1 that I can think of...
Think you're a bit off with your McNabb history
Chico23231
11-08-2010, 11:41 AM
What has happened to Vick over his career to make you say that?? he got hit in the ribs this year...but I can't recall other than that where he missed serious time....definatley not like McNabb, who has missed at least 4 games a year in every season except 1 that I can think of...
well he missed almost an entire year due to injury one year 04 or 05...??? So yeah, if your a running QB, your an injury risk. I dont think you give a big contract to QB like that...
Chico23231
11-08-2010, 11:42 AM
Think you're a bit off with your McNabb history
And his Vick history.
firstdown
11-08-2010, 11:43 AM
Your a fool to argue with this^^^^ Like it or not Vick is a Great QB! My guess is he plays out the rest of his productive career as a Eagle.
Are you calling me a fool or the person who said MV is not that good?
irish
11-08-2010, 11:44 AM
If you said that about him while he was with the Falcons I would have agreed but MV is turning into a pocket passer that can also run. He is the number one rated QB in the NFL right now.
Vick is more of a pocket passer than he used to be but he still doesnt have the deft touch of a true passer. He is excellent at throwing long bullet passes to wide open receviers but I dont think he can throw a short touch pass very well. I'm still not sold on MV.
44ever
11-08-2010, 11:46 AM
I have to believe that the front office and shannahan are trying to change the culture of the team, they passed on numerous Diva WRs this year and I have to believe that has alot to do with what type of people they were (Holmes, TO, Moss, I don't know anything about Boldin other than he is tough as a coffin nail) so if that is true then no way we bring in Mike Vick AKA Ron Mexico. Plus he hurts marketing to a certain extent and Snyder wont let that happen.
One thing that is concerning to me is:
We seem to be passing up good talent for the sake of change. I agree we have made some stupid acquisitions over the years but that does not mean there is not some legit talent on the market from time to time. They should not be looked over simply to fulfill a "change in culture"
We in times past have jumped at everyone who ever offered a glimmer of hope to what now seems like we are looking over everyone for the sake of the "new order of things" I hope we are not going from one extreme to the other.
I know FO wants a new image but... Some moves are still worth the risks IMO.