Update: Malcolm Kelly To Be Placed On IR

Brady, Manning, and Favre....who else is better than McNabb?

Brees, Rodgers, Rivers first come to mind

then you can argue Schaub, Roethlisberger, Romo and little Manning

Brees, Rodgers, Rivers first come to mind

then you can argue Schaub, Roethlisberger, Romo and little Manning

Forgot about Drew Brees. Rodgers and Rivers aren't better...they're on par at best. Give them a few years and maybe we can say they are better.

Too early to throw in Matt Ryan?

Forgot about Drew Breeze. Rodgers and Rivers aren't better...they're on par at best.

Situationally you could make an argument for having any of them, I'm just saying who had the better performances across the season.

I really don't see why they're going to IR-ing Kelly. He played all last year and he really didn't do shit. He was hurt his first year and now he's hurt again. For a big guy he isn't a red zone threat and he can't seperate. He reminds me of a poor man's Roy Williams which isn't very good. Kelly is a good kid and may work hard but he's just got too many things going against him.

For 2010 I'd take Manning, Brady, Aaron Rogers, Tony Romo, Drew Brees, Philip Rivers, and probably Matt Schaub and Brett Favre over McNabb. I do think he's in the lower half of the top 10 in the league, which is still pretty darn good.

With Warner's retirement, Roethlisberger's suspension, doubt about the Giants, Favre's uncertainty, he could easily slide in to say the 8 spot.

Forgot about Drew Breeze. Rodgers and Rivers aren't better...they're on par at best. Give them a few years and maybe we can say they are better.If you value accuracy even in the slightest, it's hard to argue in favor of McNabb.

I can't think of one thing McNabb does better than Rivers. Throw deep? Nah.

I really don't see why they're going to IR-ing Kelly. He played all last year and he really didn't do shit. He was hurt his first year and now he's hurt again. For a big guy he isn't a red zone threat and he can't seperate. He reminds me of a poor man's Roy Williams which isn't very good. Kelly is a good kid and may work hard but he's just got too many things going against him.

We didn't really utilize him in the Red Zone the way that you'd expect. We seemed more content running swinging gates and running left.

For 2010 I'd take Manning, Brady, Aaron Rogers, Tony Romo, Drew Brees, Philip Rivers, and probably Matt Schaub and Brett Favre over McNabb. I do think he's in the lower half of the top 10 in the league, which is still pretty darn good.

I'm not taking Matt Schaub over McNabb. Sorry but the guy's only done it for one year and is as soft as butter. And I'm not even sure about Romo or Rivers. I'd say right now they're probably even but McNabb has done more with less so you could easily argue that McNabb is better than both of them.

If you value accuracy even in the slightest, it's hard to argue in favor of McNabb.

I can't think of one thing McNabb does better than Rivers. Throw deep? Nah.

they're both very good deep throwers. they're just different types of qb's but both are very good.