Marvin Harrison

Is he or is he not a HoF? The guy is a monster and I'm sure having Manning helps.

I'd take him over TO and Moss.

I think he's a definite HoF. It's sort of a shame that he flys under the radar a bit because he's not an attention grabber the way TO and Moss are

That's why I like him, he just plays football. He doesn't do any of the other attention grabbing crap. His stats speak for him. It's really hard to say if he would be as good as he is without Manning and vice versa.

Marvin is without a doubt the best route runner in the game. The guy just has no tendencies for cornerbacks to read off of. For example, some guys might wiggle their left foot when they are going to cut left on a route, but Harrison, being a great student of the game spends a lot of time studying himself to avoid any tendencies and also studying opposing corners to learn their tendencies.

Definite HoF!

i'd say he is but you never know i figured monk would have been a shoe in

I'd take Moss in 1/2 a second over him. Harrison is good, but thus far has less yards than Wayne and only one more TD. He's good, but I'd take Moss in no time.

Yes, he is a HOFer and better than any Redskins WR in it's history (just a tad better than Monk Man)

His game is very similar to Monk's. He's an excellent route runner with superior hands. He should make the Hall someday, but since he isn't "the best" of his generation, he may be consigned to "Monk purgatory" for a while first.

Harrison will be a first ballot lock

He is HOF all the way. It is a tough decision on him or Moss though. Moss clearly has more measurable talent. Moss also clearly defines defensive game plans. He is faster, taller, more agile and probably has better hands. Harrison is a much beter route runner and depends less on pure skill and more on hard work and preparation. Harrison would be more in the mold of Rice and Moss more in the mold of say Tim Brown. At the end of the day if I needed one guy to make a catch or a play I go with Moss. If i need a guy to be consistent throughout a season and be a leader I go with Harrison. If I have to choose just one in general I think it's Moss by nose based on the fact that if you can get him motivated he'd be a complete game changer on every play. I would be happy to have to make the decision either way.