BigHairedAristocrat
03-26-2010, 02:58 PM
I'm somewhat bored so how about this - Would you approve of this hypothetical trade?
Redskins trade our 2nd round pick (37th overall) and a conditional 2011 pick to the Eagles for McNabb
the 2011 conditional pick could escellate as high as a 2nd round pick if the Redskins beat the eagles twice, finish the season with a better record, or go further in the playoffs than the Eagles. If the Eagles season is better than ours, then the Eagles get nothing.
Basically what this questions asks is this - do you feel a 2nd round pick would be better spent on McNabb or a rookie quarterback? (keep in mind, its very very rare for quarterbacks not taken in the 1st round to ever become starters)
SmootSmack
03-26-2010, 03:29 PM
i don't understand all the sage hate. he knows the system and has played very well in it. although i'm sure smoot would vehmently disagree - i think a low round draft pick would be better spent on him than someone like jevan snead.
I hate you and everything you represent...get a haircut! :(
SmootSmack
03-26-2010, 03:30 PM
I'm somewhat bored so how about this - Would you approve of this hypothetical trade?
Redskins trade our 2nd round pick (37th overall) and a conditional 2011 pick to the Eagles for McNabb
the 2011 conditional pick could escellate as high as a 2nd round pick if the Redskins beat the eagles twice, finish the season with a better record, or go further in the playoffs than the Eagles. If the Eagles season is better than ours, then the Eagles get nothing.
Basically what this questions asks is this - do you feel a 2nd round pick would be better spent on McNabb or a rookie quarterback? (keep in mind, its very very rare for quarterbacks not taken in the 1st round to ever become starters)
Why not spend the 2nd round pick on another position?
BleedBurgundy
03-26-2010, 03:41 PM
I'm somewhat bored so how about this - Would you approve of this hypothetical trade?
Redskins trade our 2nd round pick (37th overall) and a conditional 2011 pick to the Eagles for McNabb
the 2011 conditional pick could escellate as high as a 2nd round pick if the Redskins beat the eagles twice, finish the season with a better record, or go further in the playoffs than the Eagles. If the Eagles season is better than ours, then the Eagles get nothing.
Basically what this questions asks is this - do you feel a 2nd round pick would be better spent on McNabb or a rookie quarterback? (keep in mind, its very very rare for quarterbacks not taken in the 1st round to ever become starters)
I don't know if I could ever pull for a team with McNabb bounce passing footballs to receivers 8 yds away. I'm saying my fanhood would take a sabbatical until that sad little experiment was over.
flaskinsfan8
03-26-2010, 03:57 PM
Good. I hope they get rid of Mcnabb. I hate to admit it but my old lady is an Eagles fan and I am so tired of hearing eagles fans blow Mcnabb.
BigHairedAristocrat
03-26-2010, 04:09 PM
I hate you and everything you represent...get a haircut! :(
easy rider reference?
Why not spend the 2nd round pick on another position?
i think the chances we dont spend a 1st or 2nd round pick on a QB is slim to none.
No hate for Sage it's just hard to get excited over a 32 year old journeyman backup
BigHairedAristocrat
03-26-2010, 04:27 PM
No hate for Sage it's just hard to get excited over a 32 year old journeyman backup
id rate him above the journeyman quarterback we have on the roster and the soon-to-be jounrneyman QB we're trying to get rid of.
celts32
03-26-2010, 04:40 PM
I'm somewhat bored so how about this - Would you approve of this hypothetical trade?
Redskins trade our 2nd round pick (37th overall) and a conditional 2011 pick to the Eagles for McNabb
the 2011 conditional pick could escellate as high as a 2nd round pick if the Redskins beat the eagles twice, finish the season with a better record, or go further in the playoffs than the Eagles. If the Eagles season is better than ours, then the Eagles get nothing.
Basically what this questions asks is this - do you feel a 2nd round pick would be better spent on McNabb or a rookie quarterback? (keep in mind, its very very rare for quarterbacks not taken in the 1st round to ever become starters)
I would never give any draft pick for McNabb. He is a stop gap...I prefer to build something long term. If I am tossing around draft picks I would rather give them to the Rams and get Bradford.