Do You Want Jason Campbell Back in 2010?

Yup, although I doubt that he's a long-term answer at qb.

If you made JC sit and watch film of Kurt Warner dropping back and making quick decisions on who to throw to, then maybe he'd be better next year. Otherwise, he's still too slow in making decsisons, and often overlooks wide open receivers. But I vote yes to keep him because I don't know whether any of the top four QB's in the draft are going to be (or remain) healthy.

You're going to have to jog my memory Deezel, I can't remember that.

He was in the bottom third of the league in sacks AFTER week 5 AND played some of the worst Defenses in the league... maybe of all time. He was hardly running for his life against the likes of the Rams, Chiefs and Lions. He's not totally blameless and doesn't always need people making excuses for him. I'm in the keep him camp, but hold him as accountable as anyone for the crappy start of the season. That said, he showed a lot in the second half and should be brought back. IMO.

Huge difference in threads Mattyk

unlock the one I just created.

this one asks If you want JC on the team, mine asks if you want him as our starting QB (leaving the idea open of keeping him but having someone else as our starter...which is what I want to hear about who the else is) This thread is 24 pages long anyway, and does it really hurt to have a new thread created no.

We've beaten the topic to death, move on.

I think the point is we have enough JC discussion threads. We have this, we have the ESPN report, we have the PopTart discussion. If there is any more that needs to be said about JC one of these places ought to work. Of course maybe I could start a thread about whether we need more JC discussion. Get a poll, find out how many people want to really hash through the depths and concepts of JC as a Redskin

Mods, can I get a poll!

I think the point is we have enough JC discussion threads. We have this, we have the ESPN report, we have the PopTart discussion. If there is any more that needs to be said about JC one of these places ought to work. Of course maybe I could start a thread about whether we need more JC discussion. Get a poll, find out how many people want to really hash through the depths and concepts of JC as a Redskin

Mods, can I get a poll!

I don't think JC should eat too many Pop Tarts. It makes him less mobile in the pocket and affects his accuracy.

We've beaten the topic to death, move on.

Well being that the draft is just around the corner why don't re ask the question with people having the thoughts of getting a QB like Bradford or Clausen and seeing if they like them more than JC. We should close this thread and open up the new thread.

I think the point is we have enough JC discussion threads. We have this, we have the ESPN report, we have the PopTart discussion. If there is any more that needs to be said about JC one of these places ought to work. Of course maybe I could start a thread about whether we need more JC discussion. Get a poll, find out how many people want to really hash through the depths and concepts of JC as a Redskin

Mods, can I get a poll!

I've got something just for you

Huge difference in threads Mattyk

unlock the one I just created.

this one asks If you want JC on the team, mine asks if you want him as our starting QB (leaving the idea open of keeping him but having someone else as our starter...which is what I want to hear about who the else is) This thread is 24 pages long anyway, and does it really hurt to have a new thread created no.


Are you ordering around the boss? Do you know what happens when someone does that?