Divisional Play

But that wouldn't explain the discrepency. Are the Giants more talented and better coached only when they're playing divisional games, but equally talented and equally coached when playing teams outside the division?

I would say the NFC has been the strongest division this decade as well in the NFC. Our FO bears alot of responsibility as well, very poor players choices, horrible contracts, poor coaching, etc...

But that wouldn't explain the discrepency. Are the Giants more talented and better coached only when they're playing divisional games, but equally talented and equally coached when playing teams outside the division?

I think you may be overthinking things a bit with this thread... the truth is the other 3 teams in the division are simply better teams, period.

Look at enough stats and you can find unexplainable discrepancies all over the place.