SolidSnake84
12-15-2009, 12:54 PM
Watching Brett's play at the beginning of last season and this season really got me thinking.
Is Brett changing the moniker of "It's a young man's game"?
I think he is showing that age is nothing if you can play well and you take care of yourself. Would love to see other greybeards like Garcia, Collins, and Kurt Warner continue playing as long as they are able to....
BigHairedAristocrat
12-15-2009, 01:05 PM
No. I think Favre is the exception and will not become the rule... although i'd love to see Manning have such a long career.
QB is a position that takes years to master, so it's certainly not uncommon for the 30+ crowd to be the top QBs in the game. However, Favre is a bit of a freak to be playing this well at age 40.
BDBohnzie
12-15-2009, 01:32 PM
No. I think Favre is the exception and will not become the rule... although i'd love to see Manning have such a long career.
QB is a position that takes years to master, so it's certainly not uncommon for the 30+ crowd to be the top QBs in the game. However, Favre is a bit of a freak to be playing this well at age 40.
Top 10 QBs in 2009 to date (based on Rating) are as follows:
Brees (30), Favre (40), Rivers (28), Rodgers (26), P. Manning (33), Schaub (28), Roethlisburger (27), Romo (29), McNabb (33), Brady (32).
Aside from Favre and Warner (38), the trend really doesn't exist and they are certainly exceptions to the rule. What is also helping these 2 old farts are offensive lines (Favre's been sacked 27 times, Warner 20) and the young (sub-30 years old) receivers these guys are throwing to (Favre has Berrian, Harvin, Rice; Warner has Fitzgerald, Boldin, Breaston).
dmek25
12-15-2009, 01:43 PM
i cant fathom another Q-back lasting as long as Favre. and to have that many consecutive starts, especially the way they get hit....
artmonkforhallofamein07
12-15-2009, 01:53 PM
I could see P. Manning doing it personally. I dont know about Brady or the other top guys in the league right now. But Peyton could be around another 8 years give or take one or two. He seems to really love the game and hasn't had any major injuries.
Longtimefan
12-15-2009, 02:35 PM
Favre will probably prove to be the exception rather than something we could look to see continue as a trend.
I only know of one other QB that played at 40 and beyond, that was George Blanda. He spent his latest years as a FG kicker, but he also served as back-up QB to D. Lamonica.
Monkeydad
12-15-2009, 02:41 PM
Dave Kreig, Vinny Testaverde, Warren Moon, Trent Green...all a few of the older QBs who came before Favre.
He's not starting a trend, he's just one of many who have done the same. Now Brett is competing at a much higher level at the older age, but he's not the first QB to play well into his 40s.
I think Frank Tarkenton may be one of the "founders" of the feat.
SmootSmack
12-15-2009, 03:26 PM
What annoys me most about Favre are
1.) The fact that he doesn't get retested to keep his roster status
2) He doesn't get punished for intentional grounding because "of his age".
3) He thinks people owe him something.....
What annoys me most about Favre are
1.) The fact that he doesn't get retested to keep his roster status
2) He doesn't get punished for intentional grounding because "of his age".
3) He thinks people owe him something.....
Those damn old folks