Jason Campbell for Vince Young ? Who would you rather have?

I have been a support of JC since he has been here but today I come to realize that JC is not suited for the WC offense. If we let JC walk at the end of the year who do we have as our starter? I think the Titans would be willing to let Vince Young go for the right compensation so would you rather make a deal for Young or Keep Jason Campbell ( Soup to some of you)?
Do we spend a 1st round pick on a collage QB? How long will he sit or start right away. No matter who coaches we will need a QB next year.:confused-
I think Young needs a new start and I like his athletic ability.

Why are these the choices? What would even make you compare the two? I would choose JC over all because he is not a lil whiny *^%*^^.

Comparing the two is like having six in one hand, and a half dozen in the other. The end result is going to be about the same.

WTF? close this thread please...

Yes please close this thread

Neither. And Jason Campbell is not suited for any Offense. He's a viable backup. A lot of talented guys have made a boatload of money being a career backup without all the long term ailments that go along with being a career starter. No shame in that. His 10 year career as a backup starts next year.

I have been a support of JC since he has been here but today I come to realize that JC is not suited for the WC offense. If we let JC walk at the end of the year who do we have as our starter? I think the Titans would be willing to let Vince Young go for the right compensation so would you rather make a deal for Young or Keep Jason Campbell ( Soup to some of you)?
Do we spend a 1st round pick on a collage QB? How long will he sit or start right away. No matter who coaches we will need a QB next year.:confused-
I think Young needs a new start and I like his athletic ability.

Vince Young seriously??????

Neither. And Jason Campbell is not suited for any Offense. He's a viable backup. A lot of talented guys have made a boatload of money being a career backup without all the long term ailments that go along with being a career starter. No shame in that. His 10 year career as a backup starts next year.

I think we all know how you feel. He wont start on any team in the NFL and he is the worst QB in the history of the NFL. You write the same thing all the time...We get it!!!

Hey Vince Young needs a fresh start i would take him over Mike Vick, who some of you wanted to sign.

Well look alot of us agree JC may not be the answer here in this garbage offense but JC would fit the Titans just fine. They can run the ball and have a good LIne. Vince Young can work here because who ever plays QB behind this awful line had better be able to run.