Redskin Warrior
09-14-2009, 12:43 PM
8. Brett Favre 14/21 110 yds PCT 66.7 QB Rating 95.3
9. Peyton Manning 28/38 301 yds PCT 73.7 QB Rating 94.3
10. Jason Campbell 19/26 211 yds PCT 73.1 QB Rating 93.6
11. Eli Manning 20/29 256 yds PCT 69.0 QB Rating 93.5
26. Jay Culter 17/36 277 yds QB Rating 43.2 4 INT's
28. Jake Delhomme 7/17 yds 73 yds QB Rating 14.7 4 INT's
I kind of like my QB i would love him if he would cut down on the mental error
saden1
09-14-2009, 12:48 PM
Ill give you the last one after the low snap that was a bad decision, one was just a middle screen gone bad and a great play made by the Dlineman.. the other 2 looked like he was being forced to throw with defenders on him. which was most of the game, even the good throws he made he had guys in his face bearing down on him.
They teach you to throw the ball away in those instances not force the ball between defenders. See JC during the pre-season.
Cutler sucks, plain and simple.
celts32
09-14-2009, 12:53 PM
Cutler had a terrible game...but i still would have traded whatever it took to get him. Writing off Cutler after one game is just as bad as all the people on here writing of JC after one game...
HBnotBlades
09-14-2009, 12:55 PM
At one drive, he threw at least 2 or three consecutive passes that were picks dropped by Packers defenders.
.
I was shocked watching that. He threw three passes in a row that were dropped by the Green Bay secondary, then got some kind of penalty to get them a first down. Then he threw one that was actually picked. He looked incredibly stubborn with the ball. I'm willing to bet that's about the worst he looks all year though.
firstdown
09-14-2009, 12:56 PM
Shame our seasoned vets couldn't do the same with Giant's young receivers.
Maybe its not our seasoned vets that are the problem and just maybe its the person throwing them the ball or in some cases not throwing them the ball. I'll have to say its was nice to see him play poor which I never which anything bad on a player it would just hurt to watch if he was playing good.
saden1
09-14-2009, 12:57 PM
Denver never really had great receivers for him either, but he had a really dynamic TE, and a fantastic OL. He's got a patchwork OL in Chicago.
Brandon Marshall, Eddie Royal, and Brandon Stokley may not be great but they sure know how to play at a high level. Oh and I'll take Greg Olsen and Desmond Clark over whatever the Broncos have. BTW who is this dynamic TE you speak of?
saden1
09-14-2009, 01:00 PM
Cutler had a terrible game...but i still would have traded whatever it took to get him. Writing off Cutler after one game is just as bad as all the people on here writing of JC after one game...
Not writing him off after one game, I've written him off as being better than JC with his poor decision making that resulted in 18 INTs last year.
GTripp0012
09-14-2009, 01:16 PM
Brandon Marshall, Eddie Royal, and Brandon Stokley may not be great but they sure know how to play at a high level. Oh and I'll take Greg Olsen and Desmond Clark over whatever the Broncos have. BTW who is this dynamic TE you speak of?Scheffler.
Marshall's kind of bad, at least in his go-to receiver role. He's too young and talented to write off, but he's completely undependable. I like both Royal and Stokley, but in the same way I like Randle El and James Thrash.
BDBohnzie
09-14-2009, 01:16 PM
@saden - Cutler threw to Scheffler and Graham at TE last year (2008 - combined 72 catches, 1034 yards, 7 TDs). And while neither of them are Gonzalez, Gates, Witten or Cooley, they match up well against Olsen and Clark (2009 - combined 95 catches, 941 yards, 6 TDs).
And even with Cutler's blunders, Chicago was in it until the very end thanks to the D that lost Urlacher for the year.
Dom Capers really has the Packers D running on all cylinders, and if Rodgers can get the gun honed down, that is a solid team that could go very deep into the Playoffs, especially in the NFC North.
sandtrapjack
09-14-2009, 01:30 PM
I'm not a Cutler fan at all, but in his defense, half of the picks he threw were because the receivers gave up on the routes. Watch the replay's, it was twice with the one guy. Gave up on routes???
How the heck do you give up on a screen? One of those INT's was thrown to an offensive lineman on an inside screen play.
None of the interceptions thrown were "spectacular" by the defense. Hell Cutler hit each one of them right between the numbers, almost as if he was targeting them.