Where's McCants when you need him.

Gardner did have a spectacular catch, but he needs to learn to catch the easy ones, its the hard ones he catches.

Gardner has a had good games, in fact he had a great season under Marty. McCants had a decent season last year, and the year before he fumbled almost every time he caught a pass. In my opinion McCants hasn't proven anything more than Gardner.

McCants led with 6 TD's. I remember Gardner catching a pass against the Giants his first year catching and fumbling on the play. But McCants I don't recall that. McCants was resigned this year. Gardner was in the process of being traded but no one wanted him.

last year it looked like mccants had good hands, but speed wasn't really his thing... maybe jacobs should get a try? he looked alright so far...

i don't know though... i've never been gardner fan, and this game didn't help that...

I think we'll see McCants activated this week, just my guess. Will he start ahead of Gardner? I doubt it but we'll see.

If Gardner isn't a #2 WR I have a hard time saying that McCants is. McCants has been just as inconsistent in his limited playing time, he's almost a Gardner clone in size, speed and hands.


All I want to see is McCants in, when we are in the redzone. You can count on him there.

McCants had a tendency a couple of years ago to catch the ball but then he'd start running and drop the ball while he was running. I think that's why they started using him in the red zone so he wouldn't have to run anywhere after he caught the ball in the endzone

i think if gardner has another bad game (not that it wasn't the whole offense)... then maybe give mccants a shot... but nobody has ammounted to much that much is obvious

why not both active? Who is the fourth receiver? I understand Thrash for his ST effort, but who is fourth?

I believe Jacobs has been the fourth WR, but I don't think he has played a down....except maybe on special teams...

I'd like to see McCants involved more in the offense, ESPECIALLY near the goal line. The guy is big and grabs everything. Unlike someone else...

I'd like to see McCants involved more in the offense, ESPECIALLY near the goal line. The guy is big and grabs everything. Unlike someone else...
Exactly... A red zone offense with Coles, Cooley, and McCants. If the ball is thrown anywhere near any one of them: Touchdown! With Portis or even Betts in the backfield, it's even better.
Also, maybe if they bench Gardner for a game or two, he will actually work hard and finally play up to his potential to earn his job back.