Moral based question:

Pages : 1 2 [3] 4 5 6

SmootSmack
04-06-2009, 08:32 AM
That's the way my profs always did it too with the cheat sheet. Anything you could fit on one piece of paper was fair game.

Same here.

mredskins
04-06-2009, 08:34 AM
Cheating never pays because in the end if you get caught or not you lose. I hated hated English class when growing up espically spelling. I think I cheated on most spelling test and now today I suffer becasue I am the worst speller I know.

Luckly I took a likening to math. I would say if you cheat you are only screwing yourself. It is true in the "real world" Excel or my HP 10BII ( I know it is crappy but gets the job done plus I use Ecel 99% of the time) does the work of actual claculating the formulas but with out knowing the methodology behind those formauls Excel and my HP would be useless.

Basically don't cheat yourself and just learn the crap.

FRPLG
04-06-2009, 08:35 AM
I would just ask the professor. If he ahsn't said you can't and said you can use your calculator then it isn't really cheating to me. But I'd still make sure based on the "If it's too good to be true" philosophy.

CRedskinsRule
04-06-2009, 08:45 AM
Also, if you have it, check the rules they handed out at the beginning of the semester. When I went, everything was laid out fairly clearly in those. Like most have said, if you are not sure ask first and that way you don't have to worry.

Hog1
04-06-2009, 08:48 AM
Ask the Prof. Your conscience wil be clear. All will be well, and the teach will respect for it! And if that doesn't work for you, see if you can buy a copy of the exam

BDBohnzie
04-06-2009, 10:16 AM
Morally, I'd clear it up with the professor. Ask the professor to clarify his response by asking if calculators are to be cleared, and would you be able to program in any formulas you would need to use. That way you are in the clear and it can't be used against you...

However, what I always laugh at (not that Daseal would do this) was those students who programmed stuff into their calculators/cheat sheets and didn't know how to use the information. They just assumed that having the formulas, they would be able to figure out when to use them. I had several friends fail out of statistics and calculus because they didn't study and figured they could "cheat" their way to an A with the stuff programmed into the calculators, and then used the wrong formulas and equations.

724Skinsfan
04-06-2009, 11:06 AM
For it not to be considered wrong everybody in the class would need to have the formulas stored in their calculator. Anybody that has them stored now has a competitive advantage over someone that doesn't. Most teachers are smart enough to realize this. I'll bet the professor didn't consider or simply forget to include the fact that you can't store the formulas. Maybe, his tests are geared so that the formulas are already provided. Who knows?

Follow your conscience, though. Like gibbsisgod (do we still call him giggity or was that somebody else?) said: the professor may have everyone clear their memory before the test starts.

firstdown
04-06-2009, 11:25 AM
If you think its cheating then its probably is cheating. Ask and see what the professor say's but that might not be popular with the class as then they would all know its cheating and would loose that arguement if caught.

Daseal
04-06-2009, 11:41 AM
This discussion had gone the wrong way. People are breathing me a bit too far into it. As I've said multiple times, I'm personally not willing to take any chance of an honor code violation -- simply because the reward isn't worth the risk. Personally, I feel like if the professor doesn't say something isn't allowed, then that means it is allowed. But I was curious how people felt about something like this.

724Skinsfan -- every student is allowed to use a calculator. Thus everyone has access to plugging formulas into their calculators if they so choose. As BDBohnzie said, you can have all the formulas in the world, but practice is what makes them happen. I think I have a good idea of the basic thoughts of the community. Seems somewhere around 60/40 for cheating/not cheating. Pretty close. Interesting.

Trample the Elderly
04-06-2009, 12:15 PM
Trample: First of all, take a quick moment and get the sand out of your vagina. Now that we've taken care of that, please read my post, especially this part: I doubt I'll put the formulas in just to avoid any chance of getting in trouble. But what are the thoughts of the folks here about it?.

These are the types of decisions that truly show what ethics are, there's an argument to each side. I think if we took this example out of the realm of education and into the realm of business, folks would be telling me to use the tools to my advantage. I'm going to just take the test normally (jotting down a million formulas the second the test starts), but personally wouldn't consider this action cheating. If he said no using memory/applications/editors/etc then it's absolutely cheating.

He He He. :laughing-

I'm so very pleased that I could upset you so much. Why don't you stop being a vagina and stop beating around the bush.

Why come on here and ask silly rhetorical questions? Well I could eh. . . . but I doubt eh . . . . Do you think eh . . . .

I doubt I'll do it because I don't want to get caught. That speaks volumes. It's not about right or wrong, you just don't want to take the risk.

The answer is in black and white. It isn't a formula or some pie in the sky college debate. Cheating is what ever the professor and the college says it is. That's all there is to it.

Since when has there been ethics in Business? There is only one rule in the business world and that's to make money. That's why it's called business.

EZ Archive Ads Plugin for vBulletin Copyright 2006 Computer Help Forum