Ruhskins
01-17-2009, 01:11 PM
I think is funny how people are willing to go with Haynesworth (including me at one point) despite all the character issues he has. Peppers has had consistent good years, save for last year when he did not produce much. You can say that he had a contract year this year, but before last year he was having similar numbers to this year.
Now, I do not think we should go after Peppers, I think we should go after Gross. At DT, we can go after someone like Rocky Bernard, who quietly had a good year in a crappy team with a crappy defense.
Initially I was all about us getting Haynesworth, but the more I think about it, the more it looks like he would be a bust.
skinsfaninok
01-17-2009, 01:21 PM
I don't know about Peppers he is a Freak athlete, but hasn't put up GREAT numbers since he was on HGH!! But he would be better than Taylor and Carter!!! I say make arun at him and release Taylor.
no to peppers and haynesworth both.
SFREDSKIN
01-17-2009, 01:40 PM
Anyone watch Peppers get shut down by Mike Gandy in the Divisional Playoffs? The announcers kept talking about how great/wonderful/dangerous/god-like Peppers was and I kept watching Gandy handle him.
And Gandy is a 3rd round pick with an under achieving history as a LT tackle who's on his 3rd team in 8 years. Either Mr. Grimm did a hell of job coaching him (my opinion) or Peppers is just average.
GTripp0012
01-17-2009, 01:48 PM
Anyone watch Peppers get shut down by Mike Gandy in the Divisional Playoffs? The announcers kept talking about how great/wonderful/dangerous/god-like Peppers was and I kept watching Gandy handle him.I think that might just be more the nature of line play than a flaw in Peppers game.
People around here act like if we had a talented DL, we'd never face a well thrown pass all season, but even a talented DL can go missing for weeks, sometimes months at a time.
So I would say buyer beware on Peppers, because he's not going to fix a bad defense by himself. He'll improve your pass rush for sure though.
53Fan
01-17-2009, 01:56 PM
I'd say no to both. Lets build through the draft and sign some FA's who are not ready to get the biggest payday of their career.
horse
01-17-2009, 01:56 PM
I think that might just be more the nature of line play than a flaw in Peppers game.
People around here act like if we had a talented DL, we'd never face a well thrown pass all season, but even a talented DL can go missing for weeks, sometimes months at a time.
So I would say buyer beware on Peppers, because he's not going to fix a bad defense by himself. He'll improve your pass rush for sure though.
Are you saying our top 5 defense is bad? With the kind of pass rush these guys (haynesworth peppers) could potentially bring our D would be the best in the leage. We probly have the best depth at corner in the league, Solid Linebackers and are maybe a player away from a real solid D-line. If these guy produce for us like they've done for their current teams we'd have the best D in the NFL.
And Gandy is a 3rd round pick with an under achieving history as a LT tackle who's on his 3rd team in 8 years. Either Mr. Grimm did a hell of job coaching him (my opinion) or Peppers is just average.
Everyone gets shut down now and then.
Peppers has posted double digit sacks in 5 of his 7 seasons. That's not average play.
GTripp0012
01-17-2009, 01:58 PM
The other thing is has anyone looked at the baseball markets? No one is going to get paid anywhere near what they want.
All the money this year will be spent by teams trying to reach the salary floor.
GTripp0012
01-17-2009, 01:59 PM
Are you saying our top 5 defense is bad? With the kind of pass rush these guys (haynesworth peppers) could potentially bring our D would be the best in the leage. We probly have the best depth at corner in the league, Solid Linebackers and are maybe a player away from a real solid D-line. If these guy produce for us like they've done for their current teams we'd have the best D in the NFL.No, I'm not saying anything about our defense. Are you trying to claim that we're one of the five best?