Redskins Roster Confidence Levels [Archive] - Page 3

redskinsgirl

09-03-2008, 08:48 AM

QB: Campbell, Collins, Brennan. B- JC isn't a horrible QB. He may not play like Brady, but I feel he can get the job done. He put up better numbers then E. Manning. Collins is a great backup. Brennan will be a good QB someday.

Backs: Portis, Betts, Cartwright, Sellers. A.

WR: Moss, Randle El, Thrash, Thomas, Kelly. D This is the part that worries me the most.

TE: Cooley, Davis, Yoder. A. Cooley is a monster. I think Davis will be too.

OL: Samuels, Kendall, Rabach, Thomas, Heyer, Jansen, Fabini, Rinehart, Geisinger.
I would have given them a B+, but because of the Carolina game they get a B-.
DL: Carter, Griffin, Golston, Taylor, Montgomery, Evans, James, Jackson, Alexander, Wilson. A-.

LB: Washington, Fletcher, McIntosh, Blades, Campbell, Fincher. B+.
CB: Springs, Smoot, Rogers, Torrence, Tryon. B-. because Rogers is coming off an injury.

S: Landry, Doughty, Horton, Hamilton, Moore. B-. Landry is the only one in the group that I feel comfortable with. I think Moore will eventually become a good safety.
ST: Suisham, Brooks, Albright. B+.

KLHJ2

09-03-2008, 09:49 AM

QB's = C: Campbell is not consistent, Collis hasn't ran the WCO since EQ was in diapers, and Colt is a Rookie

RB'S = B: Portis is the main threat and he may get 1,000 yards and some TD's, but who in the hell is scared of 3 point something yards per carry? Ladell Betts had that real good season in relief, but he really doesn't keep any Defense awake at night (solid backup, nothing more). Rock Cartwright is a good guy, and a good special teamer, but he is not that involved in the offense.

WR's = D: Show me the money! I am not doubting the talent, but I need some production. Note: If the QB grade was better then this one would be too.

TE's = A: Cooley is a Pro Bowler, Yoder is a solid vet backup, and Davis is the only positive early round offensive draft pick thus far.

OL = B+ run blocking, C+ pass blocking, Overall B (Grade went up when Jansen was benched)

DL = B+: As long as Jason Taylor pans out. This inside DT's Montgomery and Golston are still suspect at times. We know that we are going to get solid play from Griffin and Carter. If EJ can come around and the young DT's improve, then the age of the starters in this group wouldn't scare me as much.

LB's = C+: Mcintosh is comming off of injury, Fletcher is a beast but getting old, Washington has been hampered with injuries the past couple of years. When they are all healthy this is easily an A unit, but realistically we are going to see some Fincher, Campbell, and possibly Blades this year. At least the backups have some promise.

DB's = C+: Springs is the best CB that we have and has easily lost a step, Rogers can defend passes with the best of them but cant hold onto them (and that was when he was healthy). Smoot is Harvey 2 face, He will make a couple of good plays and then fold on potential great plays. Laron Landry can be a beast if he can pick up where he left off last season. Reed Doughty is solid against the run and suspect against the pass, but he did have a pick last week.

ST's = C-: Suisham is average at best. Brooks is a rookie who has to learn how to hold. At least the Red Snapper will not give them any bad snapps.


	Commanders Post at The Warpath > Commanders Football > Locker Room Main Forum > Redskins Roster Confidence Levels PDA Redskins Roster Confidence Levels Pages : 1 2 [3] redskinsgirl 09-03-2008, 08:48 AM QB: Campbell, Collins, Brennan. B- JC isn't a horrible QB. He may not play like Brady, but I feel he can get the job done. He put up better numbers then E. Manning. Collins is a great backup. Brennan will be a good QB someday. Backs: Portis, Betts, Cartwright, Sellers. A. WR: Moss, Randle El, Thrash, Thomas, Kelly. D This is the part that worries me the most. TE: Cooley, Davis, Yoder. A. Cooley is a monster. I think Davis will be too. OL: Samuels, Kendall, Rabach, Thomas, Heyer, Jansen, Fabini, Rinehart, Geisinger. I would have given them a B+, but because of the Carolina game they get a B-. DL: Carter, Griffin, Golston, Taylor, Montgomery, Evans, James, Jackson, Alexander, Wilson. A-. LB: Washington, Fletcher, McIntosh, Blades, Campbell, Fincher. B+. CB: Springs, Smoot, Rogers, Torrence, Tryon. B-. because Rogers is coming off an injury. S: Landry, Doughty, Horton, Hamilton, Moore. B-. Landry is the only one in the group that I feel comfortable with. I think Moore will eventually become a good safety. ST: Suisham, Brooks, Albright. B+. KLHJ2 09-03-2008, 09:49 AM QB's = C: Campbell is not consistent, Collis hasn't ran the WCO since EQ was in diapers, and Colt is a Rookie RB'S = B: Portis is the main threat and he may get 1,000 yards and some TD's, but who in the hell is scared of 3 point something yards per carry? Ladell Betts had that real good season in relief, but he really doesn't keep any Defense awake at night (solid backup, nothing more). Rock Cartwright is a good guy, and a good special teamer, but he is not that involved in the offense. WR's = D: Show me the money! I am not doubting the talent, but I need some production. Note: If the QB grade was better then this one would be too. TE's = A: Cooley is a Pro Bowler, Yoder is a solid vet backup, and Davis is the only positive early round offensive draft pick thus far. OL = B+ run blocking, C+ pass blocking, Overall B (Grade went up when Jansen was benched) DL = B+: As long as Jason Taylor pans out. This inside DT's Montgomery and Golston are still suspect at times. We know that we are going to get solid play from Griffin and Carter. If EJ can come around and the young DT's improve, then the age of the starters in this group wouldn't scare me as much. LB's = C+: Mcintosh is comming off of injury, Fletcher is a beast but getting old, Washington has been hampered with injuries the past couple of years. When they are all healthy this is easily an A unit, but realistically we are going to see some Fincher, Campbell, and possibly Blades this year. At least the backups have some promise. DB's = C+: Springs is the best CB that we have and has easily lost a step, Rogers can defend passes with the best of them but cant hold onto them (and that was when he was healthy). Smoot is Harvey 2 face, He will make a couple of good plays and then fold on potential great plays. Laron Landry can be a beast if he can pick up where he left off last season. Reed Doughty is solid against the run and suspect against the pass, but he did have a pick last week. ST's = C-: Suisham is average at best. Brooks is a rookie who has to learn how to hold. At least the Red Snapper will not give them any bad snapps.