Who will win the punter battle?

Forst isn't getting paid top dollar and he has experience...if Books hasn't beaten him out by now he's a goner.

Frost always plays well in pre-season, then inconsistent in the regular season. Go with the Ray Guy Award winner.

Gotta go w/brooks, though it's not a decision that should make or break us either way.

I think Brooks just b/c he'll be cheaper and they've got something invested. Of course, as long as they think he and Frost are pretty close.

brooks, hed be cheaper, and younger. He will be a lifetime punter for whatever team can lock him upWatch us cut Brooks and see him land in Dallas where he can torture us with 50 yard, 5 second hang time boomers for the next decade. Keeping Brooks is a no brainer to me. Frost hits one big punt out of the end zone during a pre-season game, and people are lobbying for him as if he's suddenly clutch. Take a look at this rocket Brooks hit out of his end zone, in a real game, at GA Tech last year:

YouTube - Durant Brooks 76 yard Punt (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ut2FA9xGkfY&NR=1)

There probably aren't more than 5 punters in the entire NFL with the leg strength to do that.

thanks for posting that youtube clip souper...with that....

enuff said

I was laughing at Frost when he hit a good punt last week, ran down the field, decked one of our own guys, then pulled his helmet off on the field (shoulda gotten a 15yd penalty) screaming like he did something. We need consistency in the punting game now more than ever with weapons like Desean Jackson and Adam Jones returning punts in our division. Brooks, Brooks, Brooks. I hope he bombs a few tonight and puts this competition to bed.

Well they had Brooks punt when we played the Jets... and we open the season at the Meadow Lands, so I think the writing is on the wall. I think they were gearing up Brooks to punt in a tough staduim to punt in. Bye bye Frosty.

Wow, what a punt!!!!

Frankly, I have no clue how anyone has any faith in Frost. We've given the man years to get his game together and each year he's sub-par. Brooks might not be better than Frost right now, but I'd rather gamble on him than stick with Frost. I truly, honestly believe that we will very much regret keeping Frost and junking Brooks....but that is exactly what I think we're going to do.