Portis or Westbrook?

amen to that brother, finally someone speaking some truth up in this piece.

Portis is horribly overrated. The Skins paid him $50M... that's a joke.

MOD'S do we have to put up with this troll again???

amen to that brother, finally someone speaking some truth up in this piece.

Portis is horribly overrated. The Skins paid him $50M... that's a joke.

You're quickly making a fool of yourself. I humbly suggest you take a moment and think things through. Seize and desist your foolishness while you're far behind.

I prefer portis due to Westbrooks problems with injuries.

In other words ....I'd rather have a B+ back all the time than an A back in there some of the time.

Not to mention...Portis is a way better blocker and he is a somewhat stronger runner

both are fragile little whimps

give me a true horse like Brandon Jacobs anyday
we're talking about running backs not converted linemen.

amen to that brother, finally someone speaking some truth up in this piece.

Portis is horribly overrated. The Skins paid him $50M... that's a joke.

Show us some real balls and start a thread about your precious Brandon Jacobs that has nothing to do with this thread. See how long you last here.

Are you kidding me Jacobs is a flipping monster, didn't you see him trucking guys all year long? He's a bruiser in Maddens. HE'S MY BOY!

NEXT!

He can bulldoze 170 pound corners, all you have to do is go low to tackle him, and they will need a crane to get his overweight ass up.

Has he really though?

Westbrook (http://www.nfl.com/players/brianwestbrook/careerstats?id=WES537220) has two 1000 yard seasons, Portis has five (http://www.nfl.com/players/clintonportis/careerstats?id=POR792942).

Portis has him beat in just about every rushing category there is.

Westbrook has him beat when it comes to receptions, but I don't think that makes him more accomplished as a result.

Yeah that's a fair take. I guess I stand corrected.

Could this become a poll?

The guy said he has based his decision on a Madden game. What a dumbass

Portis is nothing more than a 3rd down back but if Zorn's offense give him the space he can have a good year. He's still not worth the money we paid for him though. I heard Portis is off the juice and has lost some weight to get quicker. Good news to hear, Gibbs tried making him a power back with embarrassing results. Maybe the old man needed new glasses, who in their right minds would try to make a 200lb back a power back?? Did he even watch any tape from Denver on him??