Vick's Value... Justified or Too Much Hype?

Yup... normally a decent WR, however he's been hurt and Tice has been trying to motivate him by threatening to give Burleson the starting spot.

Moss did ok with guys like Nate Burleson and Kelly Campbell, so I think he'll manage with Marcus Robinson.

who said they have never heard of marcus robinson. hes not a bad receiver by anymeans. Thats definitly an upgrade at number 2 for them. and for that matter, whats it matter. You think theres a time when Moss doesnt have two guys on him? I dont care if you have TO next to moss. you still put two guys on moss and he still prodcues. Daunte will have a great year as long as the Randy Factor or whatever its called is still there. Plus the Vikings have three backs taht could start for most teams. Their running game has been good in recent years, definitly a big enough threat that you cant consider moss the only guy on that team. Daunte will get his stats and put up big numbers

very good points SnC.

Vick is loaded with potential and has shown flashes of brilliance. But it hasn't been consistent for an extended period of time yet. No question he's going to be great but at this very moment I think I'd rather have Culpepper.

MOss is the man, but I think Daunte struggles this year. That's just me.

I think the injury made Vick mature and he'd be my choice, personally. Only time can tell.

Personally, I avoid Culpepper for fantasy. He's too hit or miss for me. Last year he rocked it, but the year before left many a Culpepper owner out of the playoffs. I just think he's too careless with the ball. Last year may very well be the first of many good ones, but I'm not convinced yet.

Two years ago when I had Vick, I won my league title and will pick up Vick again if I can. He's too explosive and too dangerous not to... especially if you have a well balanced team. I'd take him over a Brunell any day.

;)

well its not like everyone has the choice between manning and vick, theres two other teams that need starting qbs. Daunte is picked high becuase he offers more fantasy potential.

Good thing I didn't listen and dropped Vick way down on my draft list... ended up with Priest Holmes, Randy Moss, Rudi Johnson, Steve McNair, Alge Crumpler, and the Redskins Defense! If this game against the Falcons would have counted, the Redskins D would have scored me 34 points in my league!!! Lookin' good!

holmes and moss? how many people are in your league?