Brunell or Garcia in a perfect world.

OK, first off, I need to say that Brunell was one of my favorite players before he signed with Washington, so of course, I am beside myself with his signing. But had you had the chance to make the decision of Brunell or Garcia, who would you have chosen?

They both have upsides, but I think I'd choose Garcia.

Especially since we wouldn't have had to give up our 3rd rounder him.

Wouldn't the answer to that question depend on the sort of offensive system you had in mind?

--Phin

In Gibbs system, I don't think Garcia has the arm. But he a good west-coast style QB. I'm glad we got Brunell.

Haha, I agree with the post starter. I freakin loved Brunell, I have his Jaguars Jersey ( which is now haning next to ramsey) and another kind in my box of football stuff. and I was up in arms about it too lol, oh well, hes a skin now , I'm rootin for Ramsey but I dont mind it now.

Both are very similair and each would do well here..but since Brunell is on our team already, my loyalty lies with him.....