Spagnuolo stays with Giants!

Ok, but we're not looking for a defensive coordinator.
You're right, I give up on Spags.

I'm glad we did not hire Spags.

I think that hiring a defensive HC would ruin what little bit of continuity this team retained by making Greg B DefCor. We need an offensive mind at HC and leave the D alone! I'm not ready for a total rebuild!

Fassel has been the favorite all along, just hire him and get it over with.

Just get it done...plus SmootSmack has a man crush on Fassel anyway!!!:lol: It will be fun to read about that all next season!!!!:laughing2

So he got hot over the past six weeks and won the SB, that doesn't mean he is going to be a great HC or even a great DC. He had one great year. .


I agree 100% with this statement. Look at Dave Campo, Marvin Lewis and Norv Turner (Turner was OC but same concept). I'm sure there were more but my point is that these were considered genius coordinators and had/are having mediocre careers as HC. We need to be cautious with our next hire, especially if he is young like Spags. I would rather have a band-aid coach like Fassel to hold us together with the same basic concepts until someone we cant live without comes along than to sign a huge deal with an unproven coach and be stuck with him.

I agree 100% with this statement. Look at Dave Campo, Marvin Lewis and Norv Turner (Turner was OC but same concept). I'm sure there were more but my point is that these were considered genius coordinators and had/are having mediocre careers as HC. We need to be cautious with our next hire, especially if he is young like Spags. I would rather have a band-aid coach like Fassel to hold us together with the same basic concepts until someone we cant live without comes along than to sign a huge deal with an unproven coach and be stuck with him.

I hear what you are saying but good thing that JK Cook was not like that with a young J.Gibbs! Or there would not be three Championships for our side!

Just get it done...plus SmootSmack has a man crush on Fassel anyway!!!:lol: It will be fun to read about that all next season!!!!:laughing2

Woah! What? Where did that come from?

I just don't understand how anyone can be so for Fassel. The guy was 58-52 in 7 seasons (including 2-3 in the playoffs). His most recent NFL experience was getting fired as the OC of the Ravens. The Giants teams he coached were only rememberable for being so damn boring. Look I am not against the guy and lord knows I'll wish him the very best if he gets the job, but I am just lukewarm about the guy at best.

I hear what you are saying but good thing that JK Cook was not like that with a young J.Gibbs! Or there would not be three Championships for our side!

Well Gibbs had at least 3 years experience as an offensive coordinator when we named him head coach

I just don't understand how anyone can be so for Fassel. The guy was 58-52 in 7 seasons (including 2-3 in the playoffs). His most recent NFL experience was getting fired as the OC of the Ravens. The Giants teams he coached were only rememberable for being so damn boring. Look I am not against the guy and lord knows I'll wish him the very best if he gets the job, but I am just lukewarm about the guy at best.

It's called going back to the past. I don't know if you are old enough to remember the Jack Pardee days? That's the impression of what we'll get with Fossil.

It's called going back to the past. I don't know if you are old enough to remember the Jack Pardee days? That's the impression of what we'll get with Fossil. My question is did Pardee even get a fair chance...didn't he get just one season before being let go?