Did Gibbs 12-Man Challenge Make Up 4 The Timeout In Buffalo?

anytime something goes wrong, like an extra timeout or bad clock management or a bad decision on a play call or an attempted fiel goal or whatever, who always gets blamed? Gibbs does, sometimes deservedly so but sometimes undeservedly, so i say he should get all the credit for throwing the red flag to challenge the 12 men on the field, if people are gonna blame him for all the bad things, then those same people need to praise him for the good things.

All I said was that he wasn't the one who noticed it - somebody else was advising him. I'm pretty sure Gibbs even said that was the case. It's his call to do (or not do) anything someone advises him about. Again, I give him all the credit for acting on the advice quickly (which is a big part of what great coaches need to do).

my comments were not directed towards you specifically onlydarksets but more toward those who always bash gibbs when things goe wrong but refuse to give him credit when things go right
sorry for the misunderstanding.

merry christmas.

No worries - happy holidays!

yeah that was genius...thats was ranked up there with Bill belichek intentional safety punt a few years back

Apparently credit should go to QC coach Billy Khayat and Assistant Video Coordinator Todd Davis for spotting the 12 men and sending a video still down to the field right away

Apparently credit should go to QC coach Billy Khayat and Assistant Video Coordinator Todd Davis for spotting the 12 men and sending a video still down to the field right away
Yea, when I saw this tread I was thinking that it was someone up top that caught the 12 man thing and not JG but he gets the credit. As for the question. JG made that mistake that may or may not have cost us the Bills game. The kicker did make the first attempt when he called the first time out but we will never know. He takes the credit for the bad and the good and one does not change the other.