Jason Campbell vs. Eli Manning

For the record,

The NFC will be:

Farve
Romo
Kitna

In that order.

For the record,

The NFC will be:

Farve
Romo
Kitna

In that order.

Probably right.

Where did you get those stats? NFL.com has something different:

NFL Stats: by Player Category (http://www.nfl.com/stats/categorystats?tabSeq=0&statisticCategory=PASSING&conference=null&season=2007&seasonType=REG&d-447263-s=PASSING_YARDS&d-447263-o=2&d-447263-n=1)

Are you taking NFL.com's word over 12th's??

Oops, my bad. Derek Anderson doesn't play in the NFC. What can I say? I'm imperfect. :embarrass

I guess you'd have to replace him with Kitna, but he's got 12 TDs and 8 INTs. That's not too impressive, however, he does have a good passer rating and almost 2,300 yards.

Yeah, I forgot about Kitna. Comparable stats to Hassle and McNabb, it'll be a toss up.

I dont care if Eli throws for 700 yds a game. I wouldnt vote for that spoiled,constant DUH look on the face son of a bitch. Its an honor to be drafted in the NFL and the chargers wasnt good enough for him or the manning clan. Im sure this has been beat to death in threads past, but the thoughts of Eli getting any recognition or praise disgusts me.

Are you taking NFL.com's word over 12th's??

Well, you do have Eli's comp% at "96.53". That's the only reason I went to NFL.com in the first place. I would have taken you at your word otherwise. :)

Kitna is bad. No two ways about it.

You have to put Garcia in over him. You just have to.

Back to the thread topic, Garcia is MILES above Campbell and Manning. Campbell and Manning are both pretty young, and a very good comparison.

And in my opinion, its Campbell who is having the better season.

Fan voting pretty much ensures that guys like Garcia don't make the pro bowl.

Well, you do have Eli's comp% at "96.53". That's the only reason I went to NFL.com in the first place. I would have taken you at your word otherwise. :)

For some reason NFL.com has yet to update to include yesterday's games, that might account for the discrepancy (though Eli's 96.53 completion rate is clearly a typo).