Is Kurt Warner back?

NO I am not saying that, but I am saying that the Titan's D kept the team in the game and eventually won it. All you were saying is that they lucked out and won ONLY by being lucky. Young and the offense scored enough points and the defense stopped the opposing team enough to win them the game.

While I don't disagree with you that it's a long game and there are many factors, some are bigger than others, and there is no doubt that if the Jags had a kicker, they would have went for those 2 field goals instead of HAVING to go for it on 4th in the redzone. So it's an extremely safe assumption to say that the Jags would have won had it not been for "luck". They were extremely lucky Scobee had a fluke injury during pre game kicks.

Well, if that "8 max, but likely 7" W's are more than Leinart's what would you say then?

Hold up...I asked a question. You don't answer a question with a question. You answer mine, and I'll answer yours.

Hold up...I asked a question. You don't answer a question with a question. You answer mine, and I'll answer yours.

If Young wins only "7 or 8 max" games, I wouldn't be surprised and SAY "well, I kinda expected that from a team with no talent to help Young."

Now it is your turn to answer my question which is the more likely scenario.

Well, if that "8 max, but likely 7" W's are more than Leinart's what would you say then?

I would say, I don't care, cause like I mentioned, I don't care what Leinart does. I am saying Young is the most overrated QB in the league...While I think Leinart has more QB talent, it likely won't be seen for another year. To me this argument isn't about Leinart vs Young, to me it's all about trying to show people that Young really isn't as good as they think. If Leinart falls out of the NFL tomorrow, I won't lose a wink of sleep.

ps- Young has more talent on his team. Just cause the Cards have better WR's does not mean the team is better, the have very little else that is better than the Titans.