GMScud Presents 12thMan's "Who Goes Next?" Poll

Pages : [1] 2 3 4 5 6 7

SmootSmack
08-24-2007, 12:08 AM
If the Redskins right now had to cut one (and only one) player from the following list, who do you think they should cut?

Rock Cartwright
Phillip Daniels
Ade Jimoh
Pierson Prioleau
Joe Salavea
Renaldo Wynn

70Chip
08-24-2007, 12:14 AM
It's a tough list, but I had to let Rock go. Almost said Wynn, but I think he could be useful. Cutting Rock would, of course, be contingent upon being comfortable with another KR which I am not based on what I have seen. He's not exactly Mike Nelms himself back there though. Someone could surely fill that role. Maybe Betts if Portis gets healthy. I guess that's another issue.

Also, I don't know how Daniels or Pray-Low can even be on the list. Now they will both probably get the axe.

SmootSmack
08-24-2007, 12:25 AM
It's a tough list, but I had to let Rock go. Almost said Wynn, but I think he could be useful. Cutting Rock would, of course, be contingent upon being comfortable with another KR which I am not based on what I have seen. He's not exactly Mike Nelms himself back there though. Someone could surely fill that role. Maybe Betts if Portis gets healthy. I guess that's another issue.

Also, I don't know how Daniels or Pray-Low can even be on the list. Now they will both probably get the axe.

I wouldn't have put Pray-Low on there, but it's not my poll. Talk to the man, the 12thMan

mooby
08-24-2007, 12:27 AM
I gotta say Jimoh. He hasn't looked good at cornerback this preseason, he didn't look good at cornerback last season, and he's honestly not such an awesome special teamer that we absolutely need to keep him. We have depth at cornerback with Smoot and Macklin and Butler.

GMScud
08-24-2007, 12:32 AM
Anyone but Cartwright.

Beemnseven
08-24-2007, 12:34 AM
Well, if they were going to do something with Wynn/Daniels/Salave'a, they would have done it by now. Besides, Williams has already defended the D-line by saying that they were all injured last year. That, along with the fact that they didn't bring in anyone for any sort of competition makes me believe they're gonna try to squeeze at least one more season out of the geezers.

Cartwright performs well on special teams, which means the Gibbs Coaching Staff loves him. I've seen nothing from Blaylock or Marcus Mason that should scare Cartwright. He's not going anywhere.

To me, it was between Prioleau and Jimoh. But since many have said that the secondary woes started the moment Pierson went down on the season-opening kickoff last year, that would indicate a lot of people within the organization feel he's pretty valuable.

I say the ax will finally fall on The Ade.

70Chip
08-24-2007, 12:39 AM
I wouldn't have put Pray-Low on there, but it's not my poll. Talk to the man, the 12thMan

Pray-Low? God-Frey? Grist for the conspiracy mill.

KLHJ2
08-24-2007, 12:41 AM
Although Rock and Ade are the only 3rd stringers on the list, they do provide solid special teams play. So I would have to say one of the back up Dlinmen. Either Wynn or Salave'a. Considering that we are stronger at DT than at DE, I would go with Salave'a.

IMO I believe that Vernon Fox (though not on the list) should go before any. Safety is by far our strongest position, but releasing Prioleau is not the answer.

SmootSmack
08-24-2007, 12:53 AM
Although Rock and Ade are the only 3rd stringers on the list, they do provide solid special teams play. So I would have to say one of the back up Dlinmen. Either Wynn or Salave'a. Considering that we are stronger at DT than at DE, I would go with Salave'a.

IMO I believe that Vernon Fox (though not on the list) should go before any. Safety is by far our strongest position, but releasing Prioleau is not the answer.

Yeah, Fox wasn't included because the idea was to try to pick a relatively "suprising" cut. Fox won't be too surprising

KLHJ2
08-24-2007, 12:58 AM
Yeah, Fox wasn't included because the idea was to try to pick a relatively "suprising" cut. Fox won't be too surprising
Thanks for clearing that up. Salave'a is definately my pick even though I would hate to see him go.

EZ Archive Ads Plugin for vBulletin Copyright 2006 Computer Help Forum